research about dance pdf

An official website of the United States government

The .gov means it’s official. Federal government websites often end in .gov or .mil. Before sharing sensitive information, make sure you’re on a federal government site.

The site is secure. The https:// ensures that you are connecting to the official website and that any information you provide is encrypted and transmitted securely.

• Publications
• Account settings

Preview improvements coming to the PMC website in October 2024. Learn More or Try it out now .

• Advanced Search
• Journal List
• Front Psychol

Effects of Dance Movement Therapy and Dance on Health-Related Psychological Outcomes. A Meta-Analysis Update

Sabine c. koch.

1 Department of Creative Arts Therapies and Therapy Sciences, Alanus University, Alfter, Germany

2 School of Therapy Sciences, SRH University Heidelberg, Heidelberg, Germany

Roxana F. F. Riege

3 Department of Psychology, Friedrich-Schiller-University, Jena, Germany

Katharina Tisborn

4 Department of Psychology, University of Bochum, Bochum, Germany

Jacelyn Biondo

5 Department of Creative Arts Therapies, Drexel University, Philadelphia, PA, United States

Lily Martin

Andreas beelmann, associated data.

Background: Dance is an embodied activity and, when applied therapeutically, can have several specific and unspecific health benefits. In this meta-analysis, we evaluated the effectiveness of dance movement therapy 1 (DMT) and dance interventions for psychological health outcomes. Research in this area grew considerably from 1.3 detected studies/year in 1996–2012 to 6.8 detected studies/year in 2012–2018.

Method: We synthesized 41 controlled intervention studies ( N = 2,374; from 01/2012 to 03/2018), 21 from DMT, and 20 from dance, investigating the outcome clusters of quality of life, clinical outcomes (with sub-analyses of depression and anxiety), interpersonal skills, cognitive skills, and (psycho-)motor skills. We included recent randomized controlled trials (RCTs) in areas such as depression, anxiety, schizophrenia, autism, elderly patients, oncology, neurology, chronic heart failure, and cardiovascular disease, including follow-up data in eight studies.

Results: Analyses yielded a medium overall effect ( d 2 = 0.60), with high heterogeneity of results ( I 2 = 72.62%). Sorted by outcome clusters, the effects were medium to large ( d = 0.53 to d = 0.85). All effects, except the one for (psycho-)motor skills, showed high inconsistency of results. Sensitivity analyses revealed that type of intervention (DMT or dance) was a significant moderator of results. In the DMT cluster , the overall medium effect was small, significant, and homogeneous/consistent ( d = 0.30, p < 0.001, I 2 = 3.47). In the dance intervention cluster , the overall medium effect was large, significant, yet heterogeneous/non-consistent ( d = 0.81, p < 0.001, I 2 = 77.96). Results suggest that DMT decreases depression and anxiety and increases quality of life and interpersonal and cognitive skills, whereas dance interventions increase (psycho-)motor skills. Larger effect sizes resulted from observational measures, possibly indicating bias. Follow-up data showed that on 22 weeks after the intervention, most effects remained stable or slightly increased.

Discussion: Consistent effects of DMT coincide with findings from former meta-analyses. Most dance intervention studies came from preventive contexts and most DMT studies came from institutional healthcare contexts with more severely impaired clinical patients, where we found smaller effects, yet with higher clinical relevance. Methodological shortcomings of many included studies and heterogeneity of outcome measures limit results. Initial findings on long-term effects are promising.

Introduction

Why this meta-analysis.

Dance movement therapy (DMT) is the psychotherapeutic use of movement, based on the assumption of the interconnection of body and mind, and the healing power of dance. The American Dance Therapy Association (ADTA) defines it as “the psychotherapeutic use of movement to promote emotional, social, cognitive, and physical integration of the individual, for the purpose of improving health and well-being” (ADTA, 2018 ); the European Association Dance Movement Therapy adds the “spiritual integration” to this list (EADMT, 2018 ). At the present state of professionalization, next to the development of knowledge on mechanisms of DMT (Koch, 2017 ), and of arts-based research methods (Hervey, 2000 ; Leavy, 2017 ), the implementation of evidence-based research is crucial for the survival, recognition, and thriving of the clinical field of DMT (see, e.g., Wengrower and Chaiklin, 2008 ; Bräuninger, 2012a , b ; Dunphy et al., 2019 ) in the worldwide healthcare systems.

While the use of dance as a healing art is presumably as old as mankind, DMT became an established profession in Western countries from the 1940s, when the first pioneers developed professional dance therapy concepts, which spread in Eastern countries and worldwide beginning in the 1990s. Most DMT professionals work in psychiatric hospitals, rehabilitation centers, schools, and private practice. Throughout its existence, there has been much qualitative research in DMT (see, e.g., Goodill, 2005 ; Cruz and Berrol, 2012 ). However, in recent years, evidence-based quantitative research is getting stronger, in terms of numbers and quality of studies (e.g., Peters, 2012 ). A more general empirical evidence-base on the effectiveness of DMT will provide an orientation for patients, therapists, researchers, educators, and healthcare associations and influence professional and public recognition of DMT (Koch et al., 2014 ). According to standards of evidence-based medical practice, there are five levels of evidence (from the bottom to the top level): Level 4: expert opinions/textbooks, Level 3: case studies/non-experimental studies, Level 2: quasi-experimental studies, Level 1b: randomized controlled studies, and Level 1a: meta-analyses/reviews (e.g., Sackett et al., 2000 ). The present meta-analysis is an update of the meta-analysis published by Koch et al. ( 2014 ), tackling high-quality evidence-based research in the field. The aim was to synthesize data from controlled intervention studies published worldwide between January of 2012 and March of 2018.

Since dance is an important therapeutic ingredient in DMT, we also included studies on the effect of dance interventions , similar to the previous meta-analysis (Koch et al., 2014 ). There is a growing number of artists offering dance interventions in clinical and subclinical contexts (see Martin et al., 2018 ). Including dance intervention studies in addition to DMT studies had the further advantage that we obtained enough data to conduct sensitivity analysis. Dance interventions in this context are practices of various dance styles (e.g., ballroom dance, folk dance, contemporary dance), which aim to improve the quality of life or other health-related psychological outcomes of the participants. It is possible to synthesize dance intervention and DMT intervention studies, because they presumably share many therapeutic mechanisms (also termed active factors , denominating the effective ingredient of an intervention; Kazdin, 2007 ; Koch, 2017 ). Koch ( 2017 ) has distinguished five mechanism clusters through which creative arts therapies 3 work that also apply to DMT and dance: (a) hedonism (pleasure and play, non-goal orientation), (b) aesthetic experience (experiencing beauty, body–mind unity, unity with a partner, etc.) and its authentic expression, (c) non-verbal meaning-making (communication, emotion expression and regulation, social interaction), (d) enactive transitional space (experiencing activity, agency, self-efficacy, constructive resources, test-acting, enactment, rituals, and transformation), and (e) creation (generativity, productivity; see Koch, 2017 ). In addition, there are mechanisms such as movement per se (arousal, hormonal changes, physiological changes through movement), dance per se (Jola and Calmeiro, 2017 ), as well as specific body feedback mechanisms related to distinct movement shape changes and qualities (Koch et al., 2007 , 2014 ). Moreover, there are mechanisms of health-related changes that DMT shares with other forms of psychotherapy such as the therapeutic relationship, problem actualization, resource activation, etc. (Grawe et al., 1994 ; Wampold, 2015 ; Wampold and Irmel, 2015 ). Other more specific therapeutic mechanisms are connected to techniques of DMT, such as mirroring, movement analysis, non-verbal metaphors, imaginative techniques, meditative techniques, introspection, and focusing (Bräuninger, 2014 ). Furthermore, there are also specific group mechanisms of change. For example, if the intervention is conducted in a group setting, such mechanisms as cohesion, experience to be part of something larger, mutual trust, corrective emotional experiences, empowerment, mutual support, probing social roles, and enactive interpersonal learning are important (Schmais, 1985 , 1998 ; Yalom, 1985 ; Rutan and Stone, 2001 ). More research is needed to deepen and sharpen the knowledge on therapeutic mechanism of DMT and dance interventions, and in turn improve outcome research in both fields.

The guiding questions and aim of this meta-analysis are to shed light on (a) the extent in which DMT and dance interventions initiate desired changes in health-related psychological outcomes, (b) the moderators or study characteristics that contribute to the variation of the effect sizes, and (c) the longevity or duration of these changes.

State of Research

In this section, we will provide an overview on the secondary trials (meta-analyses/systematic reviews) and some general information on the primary trials conducted on effects of DMT and dance between January 2012 and March 2018.

Overview of Meta-Analyses and Reviews (Secondary Trials)

Four general meta-analyses up to 2014.

The first general meta-analysis on DMT by Ritter and Graff Low ( 1996 ) provided a broad overview on the effects of DMT on health-related outcomes, incorporating 23 primary studies up to the year 1995. It yielded promising results about the effectiveness of DMT across various populations and diagnoses (children; adults; elderly; non-clinical, subclinical, and clinical populations; physical and psychiatric disorders), particularly improved anxiety symptoms. Furthermore, the authors reported health-improving changes in psychological conditions, movement, body-awareness, anger, and self-concept. Nevertheless, the study by Ritter and Graff Low ( 1996 ) had some limitations. The methodological quality of the incorporated studies varied considerably, and the authors did not report any analyses of heterogeneity (see critique of Cruz and Sabers, 1998 ).

Koch et al. ( 2014 ) replicated most of these findings. In their general meta-analysis on the effectiveness of DMT and dance interventions, they incorporated 23 primary studies published between 1995 and 2012. Results suggested that DMT and dance interventions improve anxiety levels [post-value comparison of standard mean differences (SMD; for a list of statistics and symbol abbreviation, see Appendix A ), taking into account the confidence interval (CI): SMD = 0.44, CI = 0.15–0.72], depression (SMD = 0.36, CI = 0.17–0.56), well-being (SMD = 0.30, CI = 0.07–0.53), quality of life (SMD = 0.37, CI = 0.18–0.55), and body image (SMD = 0.27, CI = –0.04–0.57). They also found a positive effect for interpersonal competence (SMD = 0.45, CI = 0.07–0.83), but this effect was inconsistent across studies ( I 2 = 52%). The results of this study ought to be interpreted with caution due to several methodological constraints of the primary trials, small analysis clusters (four to eight studies per outcome cluster), and broad confidence intervals.

In sum, we found 11 meta-analyses and nine reviews on effects of dance and DMT, published after the last literature search in 2012 of Koch et al. ( 2014 ) up to March 2018. Only one of these publications was a more general overview on the effects of DMT on depression, anxiety, and well-being. It was a Master thesis by Peters ( 2012 ), incorporating 26 randomized or quasi-randomized trials. The results indicated that dance/DMT had small, but significant and positive effects on general well-being ( d = 0.29, I 2 = 38.65%), depression ( d = 0.33, I 2 = 42.04%), and anxiety ( d = 0.31, I 2 = 2.97), corroborating with the findings of Koch et al. ( 2014 ). The effects for general well-being and depression were moderated by type of therapist (with specialized dance instructors and DMT therapists yielding larger effects than non-specialized therapists, physiotherapists, exercise instructors, or researchers), but were not moderated by age, gender, type of dance , or type of country .

Eighteen specific (disease-related) reviews

The remaining 18 reviews and meta-analyses on effects of DMT and dance interventions focused on patient samples with specific diagnoses: seven on Parkinson's disease, four on anxiety and depression, four on physiological impairments, three on dementia/elderly, and two on oncology. The reviews on Parkinson's disease investigated the effects of DMT and dance on motor function and quality of life (De Dreu et al., 2012 ; Kiepe et al., 2012 ; Hackney and Bennett, 2014 ; Sharp and Hewitt, 2014 ; Loetzke et al., 2015 ; Shanahan et al., 2015 ; Aguiar et al., 2016 ). Significant improvements in balance (Berg Balance Scale), motor impairments (UPDRS-Scale, Timed-Up-and-Go scale), and quality of life were found in the intervention groups. Some of the effects remained significant, when comparing the results to a control group. We also found studies that yielded no improvements in quality of life and motor function (e.g., freezing of gait). Most trials reported participants' satisfaction and high adherence to the treatment. The secondary trials on anxiety and depression reported effects of DMT and dance on both outcomes including psychological distress (Kiepe et al., 2012 ; Peters, 2012 ; Boehm et al., 2014 ; Meekums et al., 2015 ). A high-quality primary trial was the study by Jeong et al. ( 2005 ) on health improvements through DMT in adolescent girls with mild depression. It showed increasing plasma serotonin concentration and decreasing concentration of dopamine in the participants of the DMT intervention group compared to participants of the control group. The effects on medical conditions such as heart failure and hypertension were investigated by Conceição et al. ( 2016 ), Gomes Neto et al. ( 2014 ), Kiepe et al. ( 2012 ), and Rodrigues-Krause et al. ( 2016 ). The results indicate that DMT (in this context termed “medical DMT”; Goodill, 2005 ) and dance might improve physiological conditions (e.g., systolic and diastolic blood pressure, V02-peak, exercise capacity) and quality of life, but not beyond the effects of other exercise interventions. One review on dementia and DMT in care homes showed that problematic behaviors decreased and social interaction and enjoyment in residents and care staff increased; adverse effects were also acknowledged, for example, from the care staff's perspective, there were fears of over-attachment with residents or embarrassment with dancing and concerns about staff shortages affecting the organization of regular dance sessions in the home (Guzmán-García et al., 2013 ). Some residents showed signs of confusion, irritability, and anxiety during the dancing (Palo-Bengtsson and Ekman, 1997 ; Palo-Bengtsson et al., 1998 ). The meta-analysis on DMT and dementia by Karkou and Meekums ( 2017 ) did not include any studies, because no trials met the inclusion criteria (i.e., randomized controlled trial led by dance movement therapist). Regarding the effects of DMT and dance on quality of life in cancer patients , we found mixed results. One meta-analysis on DMT in oncology reported significant standard mean differences (SMD) for the reduction of anxiety (Boehm et al., 2014 ; see also Archer et al., 2015 ). The meta-analysis on DMT in oncology reports effects on quality of life, but no evidence for effects on depression, anxiety, stress, fatigue, or body image (Bradt et al., 2011 , 2015 ).

Because of the scarcity or low quality of evidence-based research in the field of DMT, most secondary studies (particularly the high quality Cochrane reviews) included only a few studies (between one and three studies). Besides that, most authors reported that their results did not have sufficient statistical power, because of methodological constraints of the primary trials. Nevertheless, in previous quantitative research, we can observe a pattern that DMT and dance interventions are as effective as traditional psychotherapy in various populations and conditions (Beelmann and Heinrichs, 2015 ). In addition, some high-quality qualitative research suggests that DMT and dance are beneficial supportive treatments to traditional care and have some specific advantages, such as the non-verbal approach, body-oriented treatment process, etc. (McNiff, 1993 ; Barba et al., 1995 ; Hervey, 2000 ; Levine and Land, 2016 ).

Information on Primary Trials

Included studies.

All included trials are displayed in Table 1 in the results section and are marked with an “ * ” in the reference section. They were at least controlled intervention studies. We distinguished between primary studies in DMT and primary studies in dance interventions, and found 21 studies on the effects of DMT and 20 studies on the effects of dance on health-related outcomes (see Table 1 for populations, criteria, and results).

Study characteristics chart of the included studies.

NEG, number of subjects in the intervention group; NCG, number of subjects in the control group; M, mean; MEG, mean in intervention group; SDEG, standard deviation in intervention group; TAU, treatment as usual; ES, effect size. Bold values indicate the total sample of each study .

Excluded studies

We located a number of high-quality primary studies that we were not able to include due to the defined criteria. Fourteen studies had been excluded due to missing data or other reasons outlined in the Methods section, some of which may be possibly recovered for future analyses. They investigated learning disabilities (Alotaibi et al., 2017 ), children with attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (Alrazain et al., 2018 ), fornix integrity (Burzynska et al., 2017 ), depression (Cross et al., 2012 ), falls (Duim et al., 2015 ), oncological patients (Ho et al., 2016b ), schizophrenia (Koch et al., 2017 ; Savill et al., 2017 ), Parkinson's disease (Lewis et al., 2014 ), autism (Mateos-Moreno and Atencia-Doña, 2013 ), trauma in unaccompanied minors (Meyer DeMott et al., 2017 ), development of kindergarteners (Stück and Villegas, 2017 ), personal development and increase of emotional intelligence in students (Vancea, 2013 ), and traumatized children (Van Westrhenen et al., 2019 ).

Mainly through the reviews, we also found a number of formerly undetected studies from 2011 and earlier, not yet included into the general meta-analyses. We consider it important to enumerate them here for potential future analyses: Belardinelli et al. ( 2008 ), Burgess et al. ( 2006 ), Chouhan and Kumar ( 2011 ), Connolly et al. ( 2011 ), Coubard et al. ( 2011 ), Hall ( 2011 ), Hwang et al. ( 2010 ), Kaltsatou et al. ( 2011 , 2015 ), Quiroga Murcia et al. ( 2009 ), and Xiong and Li ( 2009 ).

In general, our literature search revealed that there were at least as many studies on physiological changes after DMT and dance interventions as there were for psychological changes in health outcomes in the time frame of January 2012 to March 2018. We found around 50 primary studies with mere physical/physiological outcomes, which we excluded. However, since embodiment approaches such as DMT assume the body–mind unity, we would encourage researchers to include studies focusing on physical changes into future meta-analyses in dance and DMT.

Incorporated Outcomes

Synthesizing the outcome foci of the primary studies, this meta-analysis differentiates six outcome clusters: (a) quality of life, (b) clinical outcomes (e.g., anxiety, depression), (c) interpersonal skills, (d) cognitive skills, (e) (psycho-)motor skills, and (f) residuals (psychotic symptoms and physiological change). We based the allocation of dependent variables to outcome clusters on the meta-analysis of Koch et al. ( 2014 ) and detailed investigation of the primary trials. Our aim was to synthesize outcome clusters that were as comparable as possible (e.g., by similarity of measurement instruments).

Quality of Life

Quality of life is a broad construct, which contains subscales about subjective well-being (e.g., satisfaction with life) and conditions of daily living (e.g., general health, functional capacity and social integration). We decided to further include dependent variables about sleep quality, pain (invert coding), self-esteem, and control beliefs in this cluster. Most measures in this outcome cluster were based on self-report questionnaires (e.g., rating satisfaction with certain life conditions on a Likert scale), with only one study containing observations and ratings from an external person, who in this case was a clinician (Teixeira-Machado et al., 2017 ). We assume that DMT and dance interventions might influence quality of life on various dimensions, for example, movement might improve vitality and fitness, dance might foster joyful experiences (Koch et al., 2007 ), and interpersonal experiences might have a positive influence on social integration (Sandel et al., 1993 ).

Clinical Outcomes

Clinical outcomes summarize dependent variables directly related to conditions of mental health, particularly affective disorders (e.g., depression, anxiety, stress, anger). Studies in this cluster were conducted with a clinical (e.g., persons with a diagnosis of depression) or subclinical population (e.g., persons at risk for depression). Usually, the dependent variables were assessed with self-report questionnaires (e.g., HADS, BDI, BSI, STAXI). Two studies contained an interview and one study used external observation and rating. We decided to conduct a sub-analysis of anxiety and depression, because the treatment of these conditions is of broad public interest and has been discussed in the previous literature (Peters, 2012 ; Koch et al., 2014 ). We assumed that DMT and dance interventions improve psychological functions of emotion regulation, which may be mediated, for example, by authentic expression, experienced agency, body–mind integration, and physiological changes.

Interpersonal Skills

The term “interpersonal skills” relates to competences persons apply in social interaction (e.g., empathy, synchronization, communication, prosocial behavior, self-other awareness, maintaining a relationship). Most studies in this cluster were conducted with children, some of whom had been diagnosed with developmental disorders (ASD, ADHD). Therefore, researchers used external observations (e.g., by a parent, teacher, or clinician) more frequently. There were also two adult populations (ASD, schizophrenia). Interpersonal experiences in DMT and dance might particularly improve skills allocated to this cluster, for example, the therapeutic relationship, group cohesion, and (non-verbal) communication. In recent years, researchers have started to investigate whether the “mirroring” technique, proposed by dance movement therapist Marian Chace (Sandel et al., 1993 ), fosters empathy and enhances activity of mirror neurons in the brain (McGarry and Russo, 2011 ). A link of mirroring in movement and attachment has recently been established (see Feniger-Schaal et al., 2018 , this issue).

Cognitive Skills

Cognitive skills relate to the set of mental abilities and processes that we need to carry out any task from the simplest to the most complex (e.g., skills of language, memory, and conceptualizing). Because a decrease of these mental abilities is a typical issue in elderly persons, most primary studies focus on this population. Cognitive skills were assessed using psychological tests (e.g., memory tasks, word tasks, calculation tasks, attention tasks) and tests referring to body image or body imagery, which denominates the ability to perceive and visualize bodily charges and changes. Since the operationalizations of the concept in the included studies measure a mainly representational skill, we categorize it under cognitive skills, even though it includes sensorimotor and emotional aspects.

(Psycho-)Motor Skills

The assessment of (psycho-)motor skills was conducted in (mostly elderly) patients that were diagnosed with Parkinson's disease. It contained tests on walking, turning, balance, and freezing of gait, and self-report measures on daily functioning. Only dance interventions, no DMT, were found in this outcome cluster. Dance improves motor function by training muscular activity, balance, and flexibility. Furthermore, there is a training of cognitive skills associated with movement, for example, in executing imagined movements, following music, and observing bodily changes (Hashimoto et al., 2015 ). Because we focused on psychological changes in this meta-analysis, studies with outcomes on mere physical skills (e.g., exercise capacity, arm range) were excluded. However, in our literature search, we found at least as many studies on physiological changes after DMT and dance interventions as on psychological changes. It is important to note that changes in Parkinson's disease severity were categorized as psychomotor skills , because Parkinson's disease is an extrapyramidal and neurodegenerative disorder (ICD 10), which entails physical and psychological components. The included studies with a focus on Parkinson's disease measured mixed psycho-physiological variables (as outlined above).

Our residual category contained two types of outcomes too small to analyze in separate clusters: positive symptoms in schizophrenia and physiological changes (e.g., blood pressure). In schizophrenia, we distinguish positive symptoms (an overabundance of perceptions compared to average, e.g., hallucinations) from negative symptoms (a void or lack of perception and expression compared to average, e.g., apathy, mood, and blunted affect). While positive symptoms can be successfully addressed by anti-psychotic medication, DMT seems to be particularly useful for addressing negative symptoms (Röhricht and Priebe, 2006 ; Lee et al., 2015 ; Martin et al., 2016 ; Pohlmann et al., 2017 ). We allocated the negative symptoms to the clinical outcomes cluster. Pohlmann et al. ( 2017 ) postulated a concept of “disembodiment” in schizophrenia stressing that schizophrenia is a self-disorder and is characterized by disturbances of ipseity (selfhood). They state that mechanisms of body–mind integration improve self-awareness. Regarding physiological changes, the effects of dance and DMT are also detectable on a neural and hormonal level (e.g., Quiroga Murcia et al., 2009 ; Stück and Villegas, 2017 ; Abraham et al., 2018 ). Studies assessed positive symptoms in schizophrenia with self-report questionnaires or clinical interviews/observations, whereas physiological data were collected using medical examination procedures (e.g., sphygmomanometer).

Study Selection

The following inclusion criteria were used to filter studies for meta-analysis:

• Experimental intervention study (independent variable: dance or DMT intervention, dependent variable: health-related psychological outcomes)
• Control group design
• Availability of necessary statistics to calculate effect sizes (pre- and post-intervention assessment in intervention and control group, mean, SD, N, t , or F values)
• Language of publication: English or German
• Period of publication: 01/2012 to 04/2018

Because we wanted to get a broad picture, we also included studies with interventions named “body psychotherapy” or “movement integration.” We decided to classify an intervention as “DMT intervention” if a dance movement therapist conducted the session. When the qualification of therapist was missing (or unclear), we closely analyzed the descriptions of the intervention. If the intervention description suggested that predominantly typical tools of DMT were used (therapeutic use of dance/movement involving mirroring, conscious social interaction in movement, introspection and reflections on movement and body sensations; see also definition of DMT and description of DMT methods in Koch, 2019 ), we categorized the intervention as DMT. Trials that included dance elements but predominantly used methods of other creative arts therapies were excluded (Mateos-Moreno and Atencia-Doña, 2013 ; Jakobsen et al., 2017 ; Van Westrhenen et al., 2019 ). In contrast, we allocated methods to the dance intervention group, if they were dance training sessions conducted by dancers or exercise instructors from various backgrounds (physiotherapists, nurses, fitness instructors). We decided to include group as well as individual therapy sessions.

Literature Search

For this meta-analysis, we used multiple search strategies. First, we systematically searched electronic databases, namely, Psyndex, PsycINFO, ERIC, CENTRAL, and Google Scholar. We used different terms for dance movement therapy (DMT) and dance-related interventions as single keywords and combined search terms, putting together the single keywords and terms related to the study design (see Box 1 ).

Search terms.

The number of hits is reported in the flowchart below ( Figure 1 ). Additionally, we conducted a hand search examining professional journals without widespread indexing, sending requests for unpublished and in process EBM studies to national and international professional listservs, and directly wrote to researchers with a history in EBM research on dance therapy, asking for references we may have potentially missed; we also included references that were mentioned in some of the secondary studies and that slipped by our systematic literature search (we received detailed responses from Dr. Vicky Karkou, Dr. Bonnie Meekums, Dr. Iris Bräuninger, Susanne Bender, Indra Majore-Dusele, and others).

Flowchart of selection procedure. Included studies are displayed in the study characteristics overview ( Table 1 ).

The systematic database search yielded 132 records and was supplemented with 59 studies identified through hand search. Because each included research report contained only one study, we did not have to differentiate between the analysis of research reports and studies. After removing duplicates (i.e., the same studies found in different data sources), a total of 183 studies was screened. Fifty-four of these studies (30%) met the inclusion criteria, and their full-article texts were then assessed for eligibility.

We had to exclude 14 studies for the following reasons (more information in Appendix ):

• - Seven studies due to insufficient data (e.g., three had no data available; for four, it was not possible to calculate reliable effect sizes from the statistics provided)
• - Four studies because closer examination of the intervention methods revealed that they did not match the criteria of either DMT or dance intervention (e.g., combined creative arts therapies, observations of dance pieces)
• - One study contained only qualitative data
• - One study contained no comparable control group (participants of the control group were caregivers of participants with Parkinson's diagnosis in the experimental group)
• - For one study, data were reported and included from another publication

Finally, we were able to include a total of 41 studies into the analysis (see Figure 1 ).

Coding Procedure

We coded the study characteristics (see Table 1 ) using the following variables:

• - Identification: author, title, year
• - Publication: country, publication status
• - Sample: sample size, age range, percentage of female participants, clinical vs. non-clinical sample, diagnosis
• - Intervention: DMT or dance, qualification of implementing person, quality of intervention description (major intervention methods of DMT see Koch, 2019 )
• - Control Group: number of control groups, type of control group activity
• - Time: one session vs. process, length of intervention period, frequency of intervention, length of session, period follow-up
• - Methods: type of measurement, type of analysis, randomization, dropout

Data Synthesis

The analysis was done in SPSS (IBM, Version 25), employing meta-analysis macros by Wilson ( 2005 ). To synthesize data, we decided to use calculations of effect sizes. There were four levels of analysis (see Figure 2 ).

Hierarchy of effect sizes. EG, experimental group; CG, control group; d(c), weighted mean effect size per cluster; d(i), weighted mean effect size per study; d(i,c), weighted mean effect size per cluster within one study.

Most studies were using multiple scales or tests to measure the changes from pre- to post-intervention in one dependent construct (e.g., mental health, general health, and vitality as facets of quality of life). Furthermore, usually more than one dependent construct was observed in one study (e.g., quality of life, affect, and interpersonal skills). Thus, we had to synthesize data on several levels ( Figure 2 ). From Level IV to Level III and from Level III to Level II effect sizes within studies were synthesized. From Level II to Level I effect sizes across studies were synthesized. We started our analysis at the bottom level (Level IV), calculating effect sizes for each dependent variable (e.g., scales, tests). An adjusted formula of Cohen's d was used (Cohen, 1988 ):

This formula incorporates differences between pre- and post-intervention values in the intervention group controlling for changes that occurred in the control group (for abbreviations, see list of symbols in Appendix ). The effect is standardized using the pooled standard deviation, which is formed by the pooled variance of intervention and control group at the pre-intervention level. The natural variance of characteristic values in one sample is assumed to be confounded by the intervention; this is why the pooled variances at pre-time are more precise estimates of variation (Lipsey and Wilson, 2001 ).

Some studies reported median instead of mean and standard error of the mean or interquartile range instead of standard deviation. In these cases, we used the median as a mean and recalculated dispersion measures to approximate the effect sizes (Higgins and Green, 2008 ). In addition, we adjusted the polarization of the scales multiplying with −1, where necessary. Where the polarization of scales or tests remained unreported in the original study, we conducted a literature search to ascertain the direction of the effect. All effects were polarized to ensure that a positive effect size means that the health or resources of the participant improved (e.g., more interpersonal skills, less depression). In total, we calculated 306 effect sizes ranging from d = −0.82 to a maximum of 9.61. Sixteen effect sizes were larger than 3.0 and could be viewed as outlier effect sizes that could have serious impact on the mean effect size and the moderator analyses. Therefore, to avoid an overestimation of the effectiveness (Lipsey and Wilson, 2001 ), we recoded all effect sizes greater than three to d = 3.0, because it seems that those effect sizes are not realistic within intervention studies (Beelmann, personal communication). Next, calculating mean effect sizes, we aggregated the data of multiple dependent variables that measured changes in one dependent construct (outcome cluster). As a result, we obtained 78 effect sizes, with each effect size referring to one dependent construct in one study ( d c,i , Level III). Again, we calculated mean effect size, to synthesize the effect sizes of the dependent constructs into one mean effect size per study ( d i , Level II). Then, we planned to analyze data across studies (Level I) using methods developed by Hedges and Olkin ( 1985 ). Because studies with a greater sample size are generally more conclusive than smaller studies, each study was weighted with:

To get one overall weighted mean effect size, we calculated:

To obtain weighted mean effect sizes for outcome clusters (dependent constructs), we used the same formula replacing the mean effect sizes per study ( d i ) with the mean effect sizes per construct per cluster ( d c,i , Level III). Our analysis did not correct for multiple testing in order not to lose power. Instead, the chosen method is strong in avoiding Type I error. Having conducted 78 tests, it is important to note that four results may have been randomly significant (expecting five randomly significant results out of 100 tests).

Assessment of Heterogeneity

Heterogeneity is an important issue in meta-analysis. It deals with the question of whether all included studies measure the same intervention effect. Usually, if there is a more general research question and there are less strict inclusion criteria, as it is the case in our analysis, we expect that we can observe more differences between studies in content- and method-related characteristics. We analyzed the heterogeneity of the effects using Q -statistics. A significant Q means that the heterogeneity is larger than we would expect from sampling error. In this case, we would need to calculate a random instead of a fixed-effect model (Lipsey and Wilson, 2001 ). In a random-effect model, we use a new inverse variance component resulting in greater confidence intervals of the effect sizes. From Q -statistics, we can calculate I -square, which is an estimator for the inconsistency of the results (Higgins et al., 2003 ). It is interpreted as the percentage of variance of the effect that is caused by heterogeneity (25% = low heterogeneity, 50% = moderate heterogeneity, 75% = high heterogeneity; Cohen, 1988 ).

Analysis of Outliers and Publication Bias

Due to the file-drawer problem (i.e., the problem that studies failing to produce a statistically significant result are less likely to be published than those that do produce a statistically significant result), meta-analyses are in danger of overestimating the effects of an intervention (Rosenthal, 1979 ). We used a funnel plot and trim-and-fill analysis, two methods for assessing publication biases, to explore whether this might be the case in our analysis. We also investigated outliers that might bias the results.

Assessment of Sensitivity

To address issues of heterogeneity and to obtain a better understanding of which study characteristics might influence the assessment of effect sizes, we conducted sensitivity analysis for categorical variables (METAF, Macros from David B. Wilson; Lipsey and Wilson, 2001 ) and for metric variables (METAREG, Macros from David B. Wilson; Lipsey and Wilson, 2001 ). The study characteristics were incorporated as moderators of the effects.

To compare different control group types (e.g., waiting-list control group, physical exercise control groups), we additionally conducted separate analysis of studies with more than one control group, to ensure that all other study characteristics remained constant.

Analysis of Follow-Up Data

To obtain information about long-term effects, we created a separate file to analyze follow-up data. Using the same procedure as described above, we calculated the effects from pre-test to follow-up values.

Study Characteristics

Countries of publication.

The incorporated studies came from 14 different countries. Most studies were conducted in Germany (11 studies, 26.8%). Overall, 25 studies (60.98%) were conducted in Europe. In addition, eight studies (19.51%) were conducted in Asia, three studies (7.32%) in North America, two studies (4.88%) in Australia, two studies in South America (4.88%), and one study in Africa (2.44%). Generally, one can observe that most studies stemmed from “Western” countries (Germany, UK, USA, Canada, Australia, Mediterranean, and Scandinavian countries). Most Asian studies were conducted in Hong Kong, Korea, and Japan. The remaining studies stemmed from Malaysia, India, and Nigeria. We found seven studies that had not been published yet (Aweto et al., 2012 ; Ventura et al., 2016 ; De Natale et al., 2017 ; Koch, 2017 ; Pohlmann et al., 2017 ; Abraham et al., 2018 ; Aithal and Karkou, 2018 ). Figure 3 displays the number of studies that met the inclusion criteria found per year. The search dates were January 2012 to March 2018. While dance and DMT studies were equal in numbers in 2012, there were more DMT studies in 2013–2015, and more dance studies in 2016–2018.

Included studies per year with DMT or dance intervention.

Twenty-nine studies (70.73%) implemented the intervention in a clinical sample, and 11 (27.5%) were conducted with a non-clinical (educational) sample. From the clinical populations, 11 were diagnosed with affective disorders (depression), or reported feelings of stress, sadness, or anxiety. Six samples were diagnosed with Parkinson's disease, five with schizophrenia, four with ASD, and two with cognitive impairments. Overall, there were more female than male participants (percentage female participants: M = 65.66%, SD = 27.65). Comparing intervention and control group, the distribution of female and male participants was even.

Interventions

About half of the studies were DMT intervention studies (21 studies); the other half were dance intervention studies (20 studies). In the DMT group , 16 interventions were provided by a trained dance movement therapist, at least four of them were also qualified clinical psychologists. In four trials, descriptions of qualification of therapists were missing or dance movement therapists in training (Aweto et al., 2012 ; Serrano-Guzmán et al., 2016 ; Guerra-Balic et al., 2017 ; Wiedenhofer and Koch, 2017 ). We allocated them to the DMT group because the intervention was predominantly DMT (distinguishing criterion is described above). In the study by Abraham et al. ( 2018 ), classification of qualification of therapist was difficult. The intervention was provided by a physiotherapist specialized at “dynamic neuro-imagery” intervention, a DMT-like introspection intervention. We decided to allocate the study to the DMT group, because of content-related similarities of the intervention to DMT. In the dance intervention group , seven interventions were conducted by an instructor with dance education. Additionally, seven interventions were conducted by exercise instructors with other backgrounds (physical education, physiotherapy, nursing). Six trials contained no description about qualification of dance instructors and were allocated to the cluster because of content-related similarities to the other dance intervention studies.

The DMT studies differed in the technique, e.g., the technique by Marian Chace (“Chacian approach”, a standard method in DMT; Sandel et al., 1993 ), dance therapy with ethno-elements, DMT modified to suit Chinese culture, manualized body psychotherapy (conducted by dance therapists; manual of Röhricht and Papadopolous, unpublished), and dance therapy with elements of creative movement play (for more extensive description of intervention methods in DMT, see Koch, 2019 ). Dance interventions used various dance styles, mostly traditional folk dance or cultural dance forms (Irish set dancing, Greek traditional dance, Flamenco, Poco-Poco dance, Belly dance, Tango), further couple dance (Latin dance), and contemporary dance (jazz, modern, creative dance). All interventions took place in groups. DMT and dance interventions were modified to the age of the participants. In the studies of Meric and Ilhan ( 2016 ) and Panagiotopoulou ( 2018 ), the researcher and the implementing person were identical. The quality of intervention description differed widely across studies. Fifteen percent of the studies described the intervention very rudimentarily, 22.5% moderately, 22.5% more detailed, and 40% replicable, which is a clear increase in replicable descriptions compared to the seven studies in the former meta-analysis by Koch et al. ( 2014 ).

Control Groups

To control for unspecific effects, about one third of the studies (31.7%) used active control groups [e.g., listening to music, cycling, Pilates, physical education/sports exercises (physical exercises), psychoeducation, meditation, relaxation exercises], and 65.9% of the studies used a passive control group (e.g., waiting-list group or treatment as usual). One control group description was missing (Meric and Ilhan, 2016 ).

Duration of Interventions

Most of the included studies were implementing the intervention over a longer period of time (Mean = 11.41 weeks, SD = 7.89, Min = 1 week, Max = 32 weeks). Only the studies by Campion and Levita ( 2014 ) and Wiedenhofer and Koch ( 2017 ) implemented one single-dance/DMT session and assessed short time effects immediately after the intervention. Their sessions lasted for 5 min in the study by Campion and Levita ( 2014 ) and for 50 min in the study by Wiedenhofer and Koch ( 2017 ). The other sessions were usually carried out two times per week (Mean = 1.85, SD = 1.05, Min = once per week, Max = 4 times per week), and lasted for 1 h or 1 1/2 h (Mean = 71.32 min, SD = 19.02, Min = 40 min, Max = 120 min).

Statistical Tests and Assessment Methods

To assess and compare pre–post differences of the dependent variable in the intervention and control group, either t -tests, ANOVAs, or MANOVAs were calculated. Mostly self-report questionnaires were used for assessment (49%), followed by observation rating scales (17.6%), cognitive tests (13.4%), tests of motor functioning (11.1%), interviews (6.5%), and psychophysiological measures (2.3%).

Sample Sizes and Randomization

The meta-analysis included studies with large and very small sample sizes ( N: Mean = 57.90, SD = 49.61, Min = 11, Max = 275). In 21.95% of the cases, the samples were smaller than N = 30, 34.15% were N = 30–50, 31.70% N = 50–100, and 12.20% were larger than N = 100. The studies with the largest sample sizes are contributing most to the results (weighted mean effect sizes); these are (Priebe et al., 2016 ) ( N = 275), (Vankova et al., 2014 ) ( N = 162), (Bräuninger, 2012a ) ( N = 162), (Ho et al., 2016a ) ( N = 139), and (Duberg et al., 2013 ) ( N = 101). In general, smaller studies are less conclusive and generalizable than studies with larger sample sizes (unless their methodological quality is significantly better). Therefore, we weighted their results discriminatingly, calculating weighted mean effect sizes (see previous paragraph). Notably, most studies did not meet established criteria or rules of thumb that would define desirable sample sizes to conclude effects for a certain population (Harris, 1985 ; Kraemer and Thiemann, 1987 ; Green, 1991 ). Nevertheless, it is assumed that (apart from publication bias) studies with a small sample size would not significantly bias the results of meta-analyses but contribute important information, for example, about heterogeneity and the effects in sub-groups (Higgins et al., 2003 ; Grainge, 2015 ).

Randomization is an important criterion for the reliability and validity of estimated effect sizes, because it addresses the issue of comparability of the inspected groups. Fifty-two and a half percent (52.5%) of the studies used randomization as group allocation process, 22.5% used quasi-randomization techniques, and 25% of the studies used no randomization techniques (group allocation was based on self-selection or purposive sampling). Of the 10 non-randomized studies, only 5 included extra assessments of baseline differences, showing that there were significant differences in three of them (Pylvänäinen et al., 2015 ; Adam et al., 2016 ; Aithal and Karkou, 2018 ). The inclusion of studies with baseline differences is justified here, because our methodological approach takes those differences into account when calculating effect sizes. The studies from Biber ( 2016 ), Guerra-Balic et al. ( 2017 ), Meric and Ilhan ( 2016 ), and Panagiotopoulou ( 2018 ) used no statistical tests to assess baseline differences.

Thirty-one of the 41 studies reported dropout rates (Mean = 13.55%, SD = 15.18, Min = 0%, Max = 57.38%). Analysis of dropout rates revealed that 7 of the 31 studies reported a dropout that is higher than 30% (Pinniger et al., 2012 , 2013 ; Röhricht et al., 2013 ; and Rios Romenets et al., 2015 ; Hildebrandt et al., 2016 ; Martin et al., 2016 ; Pohlmann et al., 2017 ). This was in many cases due to the fact that severely impaired patients with schizophrenia or depression had to actively travel to outpatient treatment, requiring a strong motivational state, which is precisely one of the problems in these disorders.

Overall Quality of Included Studies

Because we applied mild selection criteria, the methodological quality of the included primary studies is considerably heterogeneous, and risk of bias is a concern in most of the included studies. Referring to the Cochrane Collaboration's tool for assessing risk of bias in randomized trials, there are six domains of bias that should be considered: selection bias, performance bias, detection bias, attrition bias, reporting bias, and other sources of bias (Higgins et al., 2011 ). Selection bias relates to the group allocation of participants. As reported above, a quarter of the studies had a great risk of selection bias (or in this respect), because no randomization or quasi-randomization tools were used. Additionally, in 12.2% of the trials, no baseline characteristics were checked. Secondly, performance bias relates to blinding of the participants and staff involved. Any of the investigated trials might be affected by this risk of bias (Rosenthal effect), because blinding is a challenge in any type of intervention study. While it is possible to conceal, which is the experimental vs. control condition in active control group trials, it is more difficult in waiting list designs, such as is the case in many of the DMT and dance interventions here. However, it is plausible that self-report measures and external rating scales are more affected by performance bias than cognitive or motor tests or physiological data. Detection bias addresses blinding of the researcher, who assesses and analyses the results. We were not able to extract this information from most of our primary trials, but we assume that researchers usually know the treatment allocation of the participants. Attrition bias is about the issue of the amount and handling of incomplete outcome data. As we assessed dropout rates (see section above), we can state that about 42% of the studies are in danger for this domain of risk of bias. Because selective reporting (reporting bias) is hard to extract from primary trails, we did not assess this domain. Concerning other risks of bias (e.g., conflicts of interest), in two studies, the researcher was also the implementing person (Meric and Ilhan, 2016 ; Panagiotopoulou, 2018 ). To conduct further analyses, we used dichotomous coding (higher-risk vs. lower-risk studies), including all studies in the higher-risk category that had a total N smaller than 30 or which yielded issues in any of the assessed domains of risk of bias (group allocation, attrition bias, other bias). A more detailed description on study characteristics is provided in Table 1 (study characteristics chart).

Overall Effect

Overall, we synthesized data from 2,374 participants from 41 studies (more than twice the number of the last general meta-analysis by Koch et al., 2014 ). According to Cohen ( 1988 ), effect sizes between d = 0.2 and d = 0.5 are small effects, effect sizes between d = 0.5 and d = 0.8 are medium effects, and effect sizes larger than d = 0.8 are large effects. The mean effect sizes per study (Level II, k = 41) varied between one small negative effect size and large positive effect sizes (Unweighted Mean: d = 0.67, Min: d = −0.17, adjusted Max: d = 2.96). The maximum effect size is not bigger than 3.0, because of the adjustments we obtained at Level III. The unadjusted Maximum would be d = 5.07. Further details about the distribution of effect sizes across studies are described in the paragraphs below.

We calculated a fixed-effect model to obtain a weighted mean effect size across studies (Level I). The weighted overall fixed effect was d = 0.48 ( p < 0.001, CI min = 0.40, CI max = 0.57). The analysis of heterogeneity showed a high inconsistency of results ( Q = 127.52, df = 40, p < 0.001, I 2 = 72.62%). Therefore, we calculated a random-effect model as recommended in Lipsey and Wilson ( 2001 ). The estimated weighted overall random effect was d = 0.60 ( p < 0.001, CI min = 0.44, CI max = 0.76). In the following paragraphs, we will only report results that were calculated with the random-effect model.

Effect Sizes According to Outcome Cluster

The weighted mean effects sorted by constructs (outcome clusters) are summarized in the chart below. The analysis yielded a significant effect for each outcome cluster. The effect for interpersonal skills was the largest one, followed by quality of life and (psycho-)motor skills. Furthermore, all effects but the effect for (psycho-)motor skills showed high heterogeneity. Since we calculated a random-effect model, all effects showed broad confidence intervals (see Table 2 ).

Effect sizes according to outcome cluster.

k, number of studies; ES, effect size; CI, confidence interval; SE, sampling error;

Subanalysis

The subanalysis of anxiety and depression revealed that the differentiation of the two constructs did not lead to more homogeneous results. Depression yielded a slightly larger effect than anxiety. Both effects were medium and showed high heterogeneity. The effect for physiological variables was large but heterogeneous; the effect for positive symptoms in schizophrenia reached significance on the p < 0.1 level and was also heterogeneous (see Table 3 ).

Effect sizes according to sub-clusters.

The one-session study from Campion and Levita ( 2014 ) was the only one to show a (small) negative effect ( d = −14). Other studies that were at the lower end of the distribution were Koch et al. ( 2015a , b ) that included an anti-violence training ( d = 0.02) and Ho et al. ( 2016a ) that aimed to improve the quality of life of cancer patients ( d = 0.06). On the other side of the distribution, we could observe large effect sizes ( d = 1.8 up to d = 2.96) in the studies of Cruz-Ferreira et al. ( 2015 ), Biber ( 2016 ), Teixeira-Machado et al. ( 2017 ), and Aithal and Karkou ( 2018 ). If we had not recoded the effect sizes from Chiang et al. ( 2016 ), Pohlmann et al. ( 2017 ), Teixeira-Machado et al. ( 2017 ), and Aithal and Karkou ( 2018 ) at Level IV, they would have been even larger (up to d = 5.07). Possible reasons for the effect size distribution across studies are detailed in the next paragraphs.

To analyze the distribution of effect sizes and to address the issue of publication bias, we created a funnel plot (see Figure 4 ) that shows the distribution of unweighted effect sizes as a function of sample sizes. The distribution would be asymmetrical in case of a publication bias, because then small sample studies with positive effect sizes would be published, whereas small sample studies with no positive effects would remain unpublished (Lipsey and Wilson, 2001 ).

Funnel plot.

The diagram in Figure 4 shows a skewed distribution to the right; that is, the large positive effect sizes on the right have no equivalent on the left. This is an indication of a publication bias. Therefore, we conducted a regression analysis (independent variable: sample size, dependent variable: unweighted effect size). There was a small negative gradient parameter that did not reach significance (β = −0.003, p = 0.147). We can thus assume that the publication bias does not have a great impact on the results. Nevertheless, the fact that the gradient parameter did not reach significance does not mean that there is no publication bias at all. We also conducted trim-and-fill analysis as a more elaborate method to explore publication bias using the random-effect model and an L 0 estimator (Duval and Tweedie, 2000 ). The number of estimated missing studies on the left side, meaning the number of studies that are assumed not to be found due to publication bias, was zero. Thus, the new estimated overall effect did not differ from the original one.

As described above, we conducted analysis of sensitivity using study characteristics as metric and categorical moderator of the effect sizes per study ( d i ).

Metric Variables

Regression analyses revealed that no metric variable alone reached significance as a moderator of effect sizes (see Table 4 below). N total was closest to significance, indicating that studies with a greater sample size yielded smaller effects. This can be interpreted as a result of the file-drawer problem, risk of bias of smaller studies, or as an estimator of quality of implementation (we can assume that, in smaller samples, the intervention was implemented more appropriate to the individual) (see Table 4 ).

Metric moderators.

EG, experimental group; CG, control group; β, gradient parameter; p, significance parameter .

Overall, 40.84% of variance ( R 2 ) was explained by metric moderators.

Categorical Variables

We conducted sensitivity analysis with the following categorical moderators: country, publication status, higher vs. lower risk of bias, age range, clinical vs. non-clinical sample, diagnosis, DMT vs. dance intervention, qualification of implementing person, quality of intervention description, one-session vs. process, randomization, dropout rates, type of control group activity, and measurement type.

Two moderators were significant on a p < 0.05 level: DMT vs. dance intervention studies (between variance: Q = 5.54, df = 1, p = 0.019), and qualification of implementing person (between variance: Q = 8.89, df = 3, p = 0.031). Trials with DMT interventions yielded significant but slightly lower effect sizes ( d = 0.35, p < 0.001) than trials with dance interventions ( d = 0.81, p < 0.001). In addition, the results of the group with DMT interventions were consistent ( I 2 = 3.47), whereas the results in the dance intervention group were inconsistent ( I 2 = 77.96). Country, higher vs. lower risk of bias, and age range were significant moderators of effect sizes on a p < 0.1 level. In children, teenagers, and seniors, larger effect sizes were observed than in adults, but the effect sizes in adults were more consistent. Furthermore, lower-risk studies yielded smaller effect sizes than higher-risk studies and were more homogeneous. In clinical trials, effect sizes were smaller than in non-clinical trials, but the results remained more consistent than in non-clinical trials (weighted mean effect sizes sorted by group, see Table 5 ).

Categorical moderators.

df, degree of freedom (df = k – 1) .

Control Group Type

Across all studies, the type of control group activity was not a significant moderator of effect sizes. A different picture resulted, when we only included studies with more than one control group into the analysis ( k = 9, active control groups: meditation, physical exercises). For these studies, the weighted mean effect size remained significant when compared to non-active control groups (in most cases, waiting list CGs), but declined to a visible but non-significant effect when compared to active control groups ( d = 0.43, p = 0.009 vs. d = 0.21, p = 0.126). Especially when compared to meditation intervention, the effects declined to almost zero, which means that the two interventions are equally effective.

Measurement Type

Type of measurement was a significant moderator of effect sizes (between variance: Q = 97.92, df = 5, p < 0.001). Observation rating scales yielded the largest effect sizes ( d = 1.34, p < 0.001, I 2 = 76.01%). They were followed by physiological data ( d = 0.71, p = 0.001, I 2 = n.s.), motor tests ( d = 0.58, p < 0.001, I 2 = n.s.), self-report-questionnaires ( d = 0.42, p < 0.001, I 2 = n.s.), cognitive tests ( d = 0.30, p = 0.002, I 2 = n.s.), and interviews ( d = 0.25, p = 0.001, I 2 = n.s.). We thus can assume that the type of measurement, especially observation rating scales, is one of the most significant sources of heterogeneity across studies. We also checked whether observation rating scales were more frequently used in dance intervention studies than in DMT studies, which was not the case.

Explorative Analyses

Since sensitivity analysis revealed type of intervention as a significant moderator, we decided to exploratively conduct separate analyses of the DMT and dance intervention trials (the results are reported in the Tables 6 , ​ ,7 7 below; they were also reported briefly in the paragraph above).

Effect sizes only in DMT studies.

Effect sizes only in dance intervention studies.

We also analyzed weighted mean effect sizes according to outcome clusters separately for the two groups. For quality of life, the effect remained significant in both clusters, but showed consistency only in the DMT group. For clinical outcomes, both effects were significant but heterogeneous. Related to interpersonal skills, there was a significant but inconsistent effect in the dance intervention group and a significant ( p = 0.05) and homogeneous effect in the DMT group. In the cognitive skills cluster, the effect remained significant but heterogeneous in the dance intervention group, but did not reach significance in the DMT group ( k = 3 trials). The effect for motor skills was significant and consistent in the dance intervention group; in the DMT group, it was not significant ( k = 2 trials).

In Tables 6 , ​ ,7, 7 , changes in depression and anxiety are the main outcomes under affect changes . It is notable that the changes in interpersonal skills just barely missed significance in DMT studies. Considering the high heterogeneity of outcome measures in this domain, they need in any case to be further investigated (plus more standardized outcome measured need to be developed). Changes in motor skills are most pronounced and consistent in dance intervention studies, with the most and the most rigorous evidence from studies of interventions for Parkinson patients (e.g., Hackney and Bennett, 2014 ; Sharp and Hewitt, 2014 ; Loetzke et al., 2015 ). Changes in motor skills are usually not in the focus of DMT studies. The non-significant results on motor skills confirm DMT as a psychotherapeutic intervention.

Assessment of Follow-Up Data

In order to obtain information about the long-term effects of DMT and dance interventions, we analyzed the available follow-up data (see Table 8 ). Eight studies reported follow-up data, the mean period from post- to follow-up assessment was 22 weeks. In most studies, the effect remained constant. The largest decline was observed in the study by Bräuninger ( 2012a , b ). The effect was reduced by half, but remained significant. In Baptista et al. ( 2012 ), Pylvänäinen et al. ( 2015 ) and Priebe et al. ( 2016 ), there was a slight decline, which was close to zero; in De Natale et al. ( 2017 ), there was a slight increase. In the studies from Pinniger et al. ( 2012 ), Duberg et al. ( 2013 ), and Cruz-Ferreira et al. ( 2015 ), there was a large increase (e.g., in Pinniger the effect tripled). The authors explain this unusual increase with an increase in mindfulness (detachment from negative thoughts, ruminations, and worries, which led to a reduction in symptom severity; Ree and Craigie, 2007 ) and a personal bond between the participants as a learning process, which became more effective after the participants had practiced for a while.

Effect sizes follow-up.

The bottom line displays the weighted mean effect sizes across the eight studies and a significance parameter (p-value); D, dance intervention study .

Summary of Results

In this meta-analysis, we investigated the effectiveness of DMT and dance interventions on health-related psychological outcomes. We included 41 primary trails published between 2012 and March of 2018 that contained a total of 2,374 participants. Twenty-one of these trials considered DMT interventions, whereas 20 trials considered dance interventions. We grouped the dependent variables into six outcome clusters: quality of life ( k = 20 trials), clinical outcomes (23 trials; sub-analysis: depression, anxiety), interpersonal skills ( k = 9 trials), cognitive skills ( k = 10 trials), (psycho-)motor skills ( k = 10 trials), and residuals ( k = 6 trials; physiological data, positive symptoms schizophrenia). The overall mean effect size was d = 0.60 ( p < 0.001, CI min = 0.44, CI max = 0.76), which is a significant medium effect (Cohen, 1988 ). Analysis of heterogeneity yielded that an estimated 71.62% of variance of results can be traced back to dissimilarity of results, which makes the interpretation of results more difficult. In the outcome clusters, we also obtained significant medium effect sizes [quality of life: d = 0.67, affect: d = 0.56, cognitive skills: d = 0.53, (psycho-)motor skills: d = 0.65, residuals d = 0.47] and one significant large effect size (interpersonal skills: d = 0.85). This could be due to the fact that in the interpersonal skills cluster, many trials assessed dependent variables with observation rating scales, which yielded larger effect sizes in general. Sub-analyses revealed that the mean effect in the anxiety cluster was as large as the effect in the depression cluster. Physiological data yielded a mean large, significant effect size, whereas improvements of schizophrenia yielded a mean small effect size, which reached the p < 0.1 level. Assessment of heterogeneity in the outcome clusters revealed that all mean effects, except the effect for (psycho-)motor skills, remained inconsistent (i.e., significant Q, I 2 larger 60%). Furthermore, the larger the mean effect, the larger the heterogeneity of results, which indicates that larger effects were produced by outliers rather than by consistently higher effect sizes (see end of the next paragraph).

In order to identify which study characteristics contributed most to dissimilarities of results, we conducted a sensitivity analysis. Most importantly, we found that the type of intervention (DMT vs. dance) was a significant moderator of results. Therefore, it was reasonable to analyze data in two separate groups to obtain more meaningful results:

In the DMT group , we obtained smaller but more consistent effects. The overall medium effect was small, significant, and consistent/homogeneous ( d = 0.30, p < 0.001, non-significant Q, I 2 = 3.47). For the individual outcomes, the effects varied between d = 0.26 and d = 0.51 and were all homogeneous. The effects for quality of life, affect, and cognitive skills remained significant, whereas the effect for interpersonal skills reached the p < 0.1 level. Effects of motor skills were non-significant, thus confirming DMT as a mainly psychotherapeutic intervention.

In the dance cluster , we observed larger but less consistent effects. The overall medium effect was large, significant but non-consistent/heterogeneous ( d = 0.81, p < 0.001, significant Q, I 2 = 77.96). The effects in the outcome cluster varied between d = 0.68 and d = 1.65. They were all significant, but only the effects for (psycho-)motor skills, cognitive skills, and affect were consistent (non-significant Q, I 2 < 50%). Apart from Koch et al. ( 2015a , b ) and Aithal and Karkou ( 2018 ), all outliers we mentioned in the “Analysis of outliers and publication bias” section were part of the dance intervention group. The consistent effects for (psycho)motor skills were carried by the dance for Parkinson studies.

Dance studies seem to uphold certain characteristics that produce a broader range of results, especially in the large-positive spectrum of effect sizes (i.e., greater than d = 1.0) that are not evident in DMT studies. One factor might be different sample characteristics: Most DMT studies were conducted in a clinical setting, whereas most dance studies were conducted in a non-clinical setting. In severely impaired patient samples, such as in most of the DMT primary studies that entered into this analysis, effects are usually smaller than in non-clinical or subclinical populations (we know this, for example, from pretests of designs with student populations; e.g., Koch, 2011 ). This may be a major reason why the dance intervention studies have yielded larger medium effect sizes. Non-clinical samples also contained a broader age range. Additionally, in dance interventions, the implementation and methods were more heterogeneous than in the DMT group. In terms of culture, most DMT studies were conducted in Germany and other Western European countries, whereas the majority of dance intervention studies were conducted in non-Western countries. Dance intervention studies tended to have smaller sample sizes, less randomization, and more missing information in the reporting of results.

In sum, we obtained encouraging results, which indicated that DMT and dance have positive effects on various health-related outcomes. Most studies found evidence on the effectiveness of DMT on clinical outcomes ( k = 12 trials), followed by quality of life ( k = 10 trials) and cognitive skills ( k = 3 trials). There was also a tendency that DMT improved interpersonal skills ( k = 6 trials; p = 0.051). We did not find enough studies on (psycho-)motor functioning, physiological changes, and positive symptoms of schizophrenia in the DMT cluster to draw conclusions. Dance interventions improved (psycho-)motor skills ( k = 8 trials), clinical outcomes ( k = 11 trials), and cognitive skills ( k = 7 trials). The high variety of results, especially in the dance cluster, needs more investigation in future studies.

Specific Research Issues and Practical Implications for Researchers

In our meta-analysis, we also assessed and analyzed various study characteristics to deepen our understanding of factors that influenced the effects of DMT and dance on health-related outcomes. One important issue in most intervention studies is the question about unspecific and specific effects of the intervention . Often the fact that we pay attention to the participants already can change their symptoms (Hawthorne effect: firstly described in Roethlisberger and Dickson ( 1964 ), and reviewed by McCambridge et al., 2014 ). Using alternative interventions in the control groups helps to distinguish attention effects from specific effects. Therefore, we assessed control group activity. In the primary trials, one third of the DMT and dance intervention groups were compared to active control groups. The participants followed the following tasks: listening to music, cycling, Pilates, physical exercises, psychoeducation, meditation, or relaxation exercises. Control group activity was not a significant moderator of effect, which means that the effects of DMT and dance interventions were still evident when we controlled for attention effects. In other words, this indicates that there are specific effects of DMT and dance interventions. Control group activity seemed to matter, when we kept all other study characteristics constant, which was only possible in studies with an active and a non-active control group ( k = 9).

We compared the intervention groups to control groups that participated in physical exercises and meditation exercises. The effects of DMT and dance interventions declined but remained significant. The advantages of DMT and dance interventions were larger compared to physical exercises than to meditation. This indicates that the change mechanisms of DMT and dance possibly lie beyond the pure execution of sports or mindfulness. This is in line with other research on the mechanisms of change in DMT and dance (Bräuninger, 2014 ; Koch, 2017 ). The effect sizes observed in DMT and dance intervention groups were about as large as the effect sizes in meditation interventions. There is plenty of evidence that meditation interventions, for example, training programs in mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR; Teasdale et al., 2000 ; Michalak et al., 2008 ), are successful in treating several psychological conditions (e.g., depression, anxiety, stress, obsessive–compulsive disorders; Bohlmeijer et al., 2010 ; Fjorback et al., 2011 ). On basis of this evidence, there is also an increase in promotion and support of mindfulness-based interventions by the health insurance companies, such as free MBSR training programs at work. Thus, observing that DMT and dance interventions seem to be as effective as meditation suggests promoting these kinds of interventions as well. One interesting research issue that we should investigate in more detail is: What do DMT/dance interventions and mindfulness-based interventions have in common? Mindfulness is an important component of DMT. For example, mindful investigation of body sensations is part of DMT, with similar techniques as the body-scan exercise in MBSR training programs (Dreeben et al., 2013 ). Besides that, getting mindfully in contact with other people (therapist or other group members) is an important mechanism of change in DMT. Concerning dance interventions, there is less explicit use of mindfulness, but if we look closer, similar mechanisms of change stand out. One central component frequently mentioned in the literature on mindfulness is the termination of rumination and automatic negative thoughts, which occurs, because there is high concentration, focus on the here-and-now, and a state of mind, which allows the participant to observe feelings and thoughts from a more distant perspective (non-judgmental state of mind). Future research should investigate to what extent these mechanisms are relevant in DMT and dance intervention and how they influence the outcomes of the interventions. Moreover, we assume that an important overarching therapeutic factor in both mindfulness practice and DMT could be introspection (Price and Smith-DiJulio, 2016 ). Another central mechanism of change in dance and DMT might be the experience of flow (Csikszentmihalyi and Csikszentmihalyi, 1975 ). It is based on the same principles as mindfulness, such as high concentration, absorption, focus on the here-and-now, physical presence, and joy (Csikszentmihalyi and Csikszentmihalyi, 1975 ).

In order to find out which populations DMT and dance interventions are indicated for, we investigated the influence of sample characteristics on the effect sizes. Age range and clinical vs. non-clinical populations were two correlating moderators on a p < 0.1 level. We observed larger mean effects in children and elderly than in younger and older adults. At the same time, there was higher heterogeneity of results in the group of children and elderly. The fact that outcome variables in children and elderly were assessed with observation rating scales more often might contribute to these differences. Furthermore, the larger effects in children may also have come about because there were more prevention studies or studies in educational context with children and older adults, whereas the adults were mostly severely impaired clinical populations. Prevention studies yielded larger effects but higher heterogeneity than clinical studies. Again, this means that rather than more pronounced effects, there are outliers at the large-positive spectrum of effect sizes. From these results, we cannot come to recommendations about the indication of treatment in certain populations. Further research is needed to ascertain moderators that produce the variety of results. Regarding outcomes characteristics , DMT is indicated when a psychological change is intended, whereas dance interventions are indicated to improve motor skills (the consistent effect only occurred on those).

The so-called method effect (“any characteristic of measurement procedure contributes to variance of scores”; Maul, 2013 ) is a widely discussed limitation of intervention studies. Thus, we assessed and analyzed methodological characteristics of studies. We found one significant moderator, type of measurement , and two moderators that reached a p < 0.1 level, country of publication and methodological quality of study (risk of bias, randomization, sample size). Observation rating scales yielded the largest effect sizes followed by physiological data, motor tests, self-report questionnaires, cognitive tests, and interviews. Some measurements may be superior to detect changes or more sensitive to certain risks of bias, therefore producing larger effects than others. For example, observation rating scales and self-report questionnaires are more likely to be affected by expectation effects, which will be discussed further in the limitations of the present study paragraph. However, it is important to mention that method effects can also systematically bias the results. There was also a correlation between country of publication and methodological characteristics of the trials (risk of bias, randomization, sample size), with both factors having a slight influence on the observed effects. This is not surprising, because standards and traditions of research vary between countries. In countries with less evidence-based research traditions, methodological standards tend to be less strict and resulting effects tend to be larger. However, the effect of country could also be related to other cultural factors such as experience with the specific dance form, or the (sub-)cultural value system around dance, which may all influence motivation for and responsiveness to treatment.

We also analyzed whether the intensity of treatment had an influence on effect sizes. The intensity of treatment was indicated by three factors: duration of the whole treatment, duration of one session, and frequency of treatment. None of these factors reached significance. Frequency of treatment was closest to significance (β = 0.1375, p = 0.091), indicating that higher frequency of treatment corresponded with slightly higher effect sizes.

In the last paragraphs, we discussed moderators that showed a significant influence on the effects of DMT and dance in our sensitivity analysis. However, we assume that there are more potentially important moderators of effects , which we were not able to address in our analysis. In the literature, there are factors that we can allocate to four clusters: (a) factors that relate to characteristics of the participants, (b) factors that relate to characteristics of the intervention, (c) factors that relate to characteristics of the implementing person, and (d) factors of environment and factors that relate to the relation between persons involved.

Firstly, we will discuss characteristics of participants. Savill et al. ( 2017 ) stated that gender is an important moderator for the effectiveness of body psychotherapy on negative symptoms in schizophrenia. They performed a secondary analysis with the data of a large multicenter randomized controlled trial by Priebe et al. ( 2016 ), the so-called “NESS paper.” The interaction between gender and treatment allocation as a predictor of outcomes was examined in 275 participants (72 women and 203 men) randomized to either a body psychotherapy or a Pilates group (for a critique of the study, particularly its control group selection, see the last paragraph of the discussion on the need for mechanism studies). Negative symptoms in schizophrenia “were found to significantly decrease in women randomized to the body psychotherapy condition in comparison to Pilates, while no such effect was detected in men” (Savill et al., 2017 , p. 1). To approach this issue, we also assessed percentages of female participants in intervention and control groups in our meta-analysis. We conducted a sensitivity analysis using the total percentage of female participants and the relation between female and male participants of intervention group and control group as a moderator. We found no significant influence of gender. This type of analysis has low power, which means that there is a high risk for a β-error. Thus, future research needs to investigate whether gender is an important moderator of effects. Further potential participant-related factors are self-efficacy or outcome expectations (Murrock and Madigan, 2008 ), attitude toward intervention (treatment adherence, motivation), and previous dance experiences. Regarding characteristics of DMT interventions, there is a high variety of methods and therapeutic styles, because only a few of the trials included manualized implementation of treatment (Martin et al., 2016 ; Priebe et al., 2016 ). Dance instructors used many different dance styles and teaching approaches. Although it was not possible in our meta-analysis, it would be useful to investigate differences between the effects of several methods and styles in the DMT and dance spectrum, in order to gain more knowledge about differential indications (Koch, 2019 ) and therapeutic factors. In her meta-analysis, Peters ( 2012 ) found qualification of therapist to be a significant moderator of effects. Concerning environmental factors, she discussed the influence of social support . Murrock and Madigan ( 2008 ) found that social support from friends mediated the effect between culturally specific dance and lifestyle physical activity. Finally, as in most therapeutic interventions, the relationship between the therapist and the participant is important (Grawe et al., 1994 ; Wampold and Irmel, 2015 ). As previously mentioned in the Introduction, the relationship between participants (group cohesion) is also assumed to be an important mediator of effects (Schmais, 1985 , 1998 ; Yalom, 1985 ) in interventions that are conducted in a group setting.

It is always difficult to observe long-term effects in meta-analyses. In our sample, only eight of the included trials reported follow-up data (mean period: 22 weeks). The analyses yielded various results, but most effects remained constant or increased. Regarding the encouraging follow-up findings, we assume that DMT and dance interventions have the potential to initiate a learning process (body access, interoception, insight) that might instigate positive changes several months after the intervention. Additionally, it is plausible that the permanence of effects depends on the participants' behavior after the intervention, such as revising what they have learned, continuing dance or movement classes, or maintaining contact with the other participants. Further research needs to follow to investigate long-term effects and their moderators.

Limitations

One of the biggest limitations of our present study was the heterogeneity of results, which occurred due to mild inclusion criteria and various study characteristics of the included trials. The heterogeneity mostly concerned the dance intervention studies, whereas the DMT studies were rather homogeneous. Heterogeneity was caused, for example, by dissimilarities in methodological designs of studies, methods of interventions, and sample characteristics. Besides that, we observed effects on several different health-related psychological outcomes. For this reason, we employed a random-effect model, which considers that not all studies measure the same effect. Consequently, we obtained broad 95% confidence intervals, meaning that the “true effects” could also be much larger or smaller than the weighted mean effect sizes reported in this paper (e.g., some of the confidence intervals varied between no effect and medium effects or small effects and large effects). Such results are less conclusive. This leads to a typical critique of meta-analysis as “ comparing apples and oranges ” (Sharpe, 1997 ), which means that non-comparable outcomes are unjustifiably compared with each other. Yet, in cases where there is not a lot of evidence, it might be a useful start, if we want to obtain information about “fruits”—to stay in the metaphor. However, we should be aware that we lose specific information about discrete sorts of fruits and mostly create a starting point to generate useful hypotheses for future, more specific secondary analyses and primary trials.

Our meta-analysis is one of the first in the field to conduct sensitivity analysis , which is one approach to deepen the understanding about the sources of heterogeneity. Nevertheless, it is impossible to detect all important factors and to draw firm conclusions about causal relationships between those factors. The strength of our paper is that it provides a broad overview of current research on the therapeutic use of dance as an orientation for researchers (summarize findings, identify explanatory variables, help identifying research gaps and develop research questions, control standards of research). It informedly transfers knowledge about the effectiveness of DMT and dance interventions to practitioners, clients, and public decision-makers. However, the disadvantage of broad analyses is that we only obtain results for a rough orientation. It is the assignment of secondary analyses with more narrow research questions (such as provided in Cochrane Reviews for single clinical populations) to gain sharp and more detailed knowledge about the effectiveness of DMT and dance interventions and the interdependency with contributing contextual factors.

Another issue is the so-called “garbage-in–garbage-out problem,” meaning that the results are less conclusive if we include primary outcome trials with poor methodological quality. In the present study, we also included studies with considerable methodological constraints (e.g., small N , no randomization, high dropout, deficient report of implementation or statistics, conflicts of interest). The most important question is how much the methodological constraints may systematically bias the results reported in this paper (the weighted medium effect sizes). We approached the methodological variety of primary trials with sensitivity analysis. There was a tendency that more outliers, especially with large effect sizes, were studies with more severe methodological constraints. “Higher vs. lower risk studies” was a moderator of effects on a p < 0.1 level. The medium effect size in “lower risk studies” was d = 0.48 ( p < 0.001, I 2 = 8.68%), which is slightly lower and more homogeneous than the overall weighted mean effect size ( d = 0.60, p = 0.001, I 2 = 72.62%). This might be a hint that studies with more significant methodological constraints tend to overestimate the effects of DMT and dance. Since all of these problems were more pronounced in the dance intervention studies, one resulting recommendation is to separate DMT and dance intervention studies in the next general meta-analysis.

One important source of bias might be the “Rosenthal effect” or expectancy effect , which means that the expectations of the researcher are subtly communicated to the participants. By guessing the goal of the research, participants try to comply with its assumed goal (Rosenthal, 1966 ). Thus, self-report-questionnaires or observation rating scales are more prone to bias than cognitive, physiological, or motor test, which are somewhat less subjective, but still reactive (note that the reactiveness of measurement type ranked differently in our study as indicated above). Furthermore, it is possible that researchers tend to analyze, interpret, and report results in favor of positive effects, because of their own expectancies or potential conflicts of interest.

Another critical element that might contribute to the fact that higher-risk studies yielded larger effect sizes could be publication bias . One criterion of methodological quality of study was sample size. If there is publication bias, smaller studies yield larger effects, on average, because smaller studies, which did not detect positive effects, remained unpublished. In the distribution of our sample of primary trials, there was a small tendency for publication bias, which did not affect our results significantly (see Methods section). Furthermore, smaller studies yielding larger effects could also be explained by the fact that, in smaller samples, the intervention was more tailored to the individual and therefore more focused.

Apart from quality of included trials, quantity of studies is also a matter in meta-analysis. Compared to Koch et al. ( 2014 ), we obtained larger analysis clusters; however, especially for interpersonal skills, cognitive skills, and (psycho-)motor outcomes, more research is needed to obtain more meaningful results. The advantage of a bigger sample per outcome would be that more homogeneous clusters could be considered and addressed with sensitivity analysis. In addition, several included trials were conducted by the same research group (total: 7 of 41 trials by Koch et al., 2019 ), which is a threat to external validity. This is particularly relevant, when it comes to analysis of clusters (DMT group: 7 of 21 trials, clinical outcome cluster: 4 of 12 trials, interpersonal skills trials: 2 of 6 studies by the research group of Koch et al., 2019 ).

Finally, there is a general discussion on the issue of whether quantitative analyses are the appropriate means to evaluate the therapeutic use of dance. Borg ( 1993 ) stated that the dilemma of scientific (positivistic) research in behavioral sciences is that it applies traditional concepts of physical science to the study of living organisms, although living organisms are far more complex than physical objects of study. The authors imply that naturally dynamic, interdependent networks of factors involved in psychological phenomena are sometimes hard to detect when we apply concepts of causality, predictability, and scientific reducibility. This argument is underlined by a vivid discussion on the ecological validity of studies reducing complex processes, such as an aesthetic experience or the impact of art perception and production on health, into its single components (see e.g., Christensen and Jola, 2015 ). While quantitative methods are helpful for generating facts and explanations, qualitative methods might be more suitable for meaning-making and understanding of such (Berrol, 2000 ). In order to overcome the gaps between a non-linear reality and linear means of investigation, and to generate new scientific insights, quantitative research ought to be applied together with qualitative research, ideally in mixed-methods designs that reflect the epistemological background assumptions of the studied processes.

Hervey ( 2000 ) takes the discussion a step further by stating that artistic inquiry is needed to adequately reflect the results of such process-oriented domains as DMT. She introduces the concept of artistic inquiry, as part of arts-based research to DMT, which implies the use of the respective art form (dance) not only as an intervention to help the recipient but also as a form of data assessment, analysis, and presentation that aims at answering the research question. Leavy's textbook (2017) is the basic source for arts-based research today, providing a terminological and historical overview and best practice examples of arts-based research. Best practice examples of specific and particularly well-described arts-based research methods are Jola's embodied neuroscience (Jola, 2013 ), and Eberhard's aesthetic answering (Lange et al., in press ), both participatory approaches with the researcher in an active embodied role, diving into non-verbal processes to inform and answer the research question. However, at this point, final recommendations about arts-based research as a method are difficult, because the field is young and in a dynamic development (Leavy, 2017 ). Generally, non-verbal methods employing DMT or dance may detect changes in psychological outcomes that are not necessarily accessible with traditional methods and thus create innovative knowledge.

Recommendations for Future Research

This meta-analysis shows that quantitative research on the therapeutic use of dance is augmenting. However, there is still an urgent quest for more trials with rigorous standards in respect to the chosen way of research (quantitative, qualitative, arts-based). Quantitative trials should consider larger sample sizes, randomized controlled designs, and active control groups, which compare DMT and dance interventions to other psychotherapeutic interventions with existing knowledge about therapeutic mechanisms (different types of psychodynamic therapies, cognitive behavioral therapy, pharmacological therapy). Furthermore, a detailed description of the intervention and its implementation is necessary (e.g., for replications). To avoid bias, there should be as much blinding as possible involved in the process. While complete blinding is not possible in therapy studies (and should thus not be part of the quality assessment of therapeutic trials to add this critique here), blinding of the randomization process and the accessor should be standard. Researchers ought to employ assessment tools that are least sensitive to expectation effects (e.g., standardized tests, psychophysiological measurement). All relevant treatment conditions should be reported in as much detail as possible (e.g., sample characteristics, characteristics of therapists, dropouts, structure and content of the treatment, other therapies provided, and interim circumstances, i.e., all “external” events that occurred in the time of the treatment, such as change of partner or job, etc.). Statistical results should be reported in detail including results that were not in line with the central hypotheses of the papers and descriptive statistics (means, standard deviations, and sample sizes in each group). To provide information on the impact of a treatment, long-term effects must be considered. Therefore, we highly recommend including follow-up assessment in intervention studies on the therapeutic use of DMT and dance.

In order to obtain more comparable research across the globe, there should be more communication between researchers, and they should strive for international standards. We recommend researchers conducting future meta-analyses to include more precise assessment of risk of bias, than was possible here. In addition, systematic analyses of moderators of effects should be performed in the future. Because we observed many dissimilarities between DMT and dance intervention studies, we recommend analysing those two types of studies separately in future studies.

Finally, to draw conclusions for practice, there is a need to complement quantitative research inquiry with qualitative and arts-based research (best in mixed-methods designs, reflecting the epistemological framework) and with clinical mechanism studies.

Mechanism Research Needs to Inform Outcome Research

The urgent need for mechanism studies (Kazdin, 2007 ) and their interdependency with outcome studies shall here be exemplified with the debate around the included “NESS paper” (Priebe et al., 2016 ). Priebe et al. ( 2016 ) tested the decrease of negative symptoms in patients with schizophrenia after movement therapy (i.e., body psychotherapy, BPT, conducted by dance movement therapists; for definition of these terms, see Martin et al., 2016 ) in a randomized sample of N = 275 participants. They found that “the adjusted difference in negative symptoms was 0.03 (95% CI −1.11 to 1.17), indicating no benefit from body psychotherapy. Small improvements in expressive deficits and movement disorder symptoms were detected in favor of body psychotherapy. No other outcomes were significantly different.” With the interpretation of these findings, the authors question other relevant studies of the field, including their own earlier work (see Röhricht and Priebe, 2006 ; Lee et al., 2015 ; and Martin et al., 2016 —the latter a study from the same year, employing the same treatment manual (Röhricht and Papadopolous, unpublished). with a TAU control group, showing a significant reduction of negative affect after DMT (measured with the SANS). The NESS paper's data were mixed though, and further analyses in the secondary trial of Savill et al. ( 2017 ) have shown that the null effect discussed in the NESS paper was only true for men, not for women after the intervention.

Three arguments call for the necessity of a reappraisal of the NESS paper: the problematic domain overgeneralization from DMT/BPT to all arts therapies (domain and terminology-related aspect), the control group selection (DMT/BPT vs. Pilates), and the selective reporting and shortfall in conclusions, which do not appropriately reflect what is evidenced in the data (e.g., from the measures of negative symptoms, the PANSS showed no significant difference between groups, whereas the CAINS did; SANS, PANSS, and CAINS are all standardized observational measures to assess positive and negative symptoms of schizophrenia). In the context of the mechanism problem, we will merely discuss the second argument here.

Active control groups are recommended for most studies by the increasing standards of the evidence-based medicine. Priebe et al. ( 2016 ) thus tried to implement a suitable active control group. From the perspective of DMT though, with its present pronounced research on therapeutic mechanisms, Pilates is not a suited control group to DMT. Both interventions, DMT/BPT and Pilates, employ methods that are suited to increase body awareness. In Pilates, the torso is the focus of the work, the muscle tone is actively controlled and altered in specific regions of the torso, the muscles are strengthened and stretched, and the practice includes breath work for bringing the movements of the torso in resonance with the breath. Pilates had the goal of addressing the trinity of body, mind, and spirit in a holistic way (“Return to Life through Contrology,” Pilates and Miller, 1945 ). In DMT theory, the torso is the seat of the emotions, and the breath brings the emotions to the fore: on the basis of DMT core knowledge, the work with the torso and breath is the direct pathway to sensation, experience, and expression of emotions (e.g., Caldwell, 1996 ). Thus, the resulting null findings on the PANSS are not surprising. While we know very little about the mechanisms of BPT and DMT, we know even less about the mechanisms of Pilates and other body practices. Thus, it is very difficult, if not impossible, to select suitable active control groups for DMT studies, without any knowledge of either intervention's main mechanisms. This example shows that good outcome research needs scholarly mechanisms research (Hayes, 2013 ) and that there is a strong interdependency between these two types of clinical research.

Because mechanisms of DMT/BPT are not well-researched, and even less so mechanisms of Pilates, both the experimental group and the control group may have experienced similar working mechanisms, which may have caused the inconclusive results. As long as the major mechanisms of these therapies remain unclear, it is hard to draw any valid conclusions from the according outcome research. Thus, the effect of DMT/BPT on the reduction of negative symptoms needs to be investigated with a range of control groups. Primarily therapeutic mechanisms of DMT/BPT and potential control interventions, respectively, need to be further investigated, before conducting another primary study of the scope of the NESS paper. With this paragraph, we hope to have illustrated the urgent need for mechanisms studies due to their intricate interdependency with outcome research.

In conclusion, the results of our meta-analysis suggest that therapeutic use of dance potentially affects various health-related psychological outcomes. In total, there was a medium significant overall effect based on heterogeneous results. However, since type of intervention was a significant source of heterogeneity, we explored trials on DMT and trials on dance interventions in two separate groups. We found empirical evidence that DMT consistently and with a high homogeneity improved affect-related psychological conditions by decreasing anxiety and depression levels, and increased quality of life and cognitive skills. Concerning interpersonal skills, the effect reached the p < 0.1 level. More high-quality primary studies need to be conducted and included into meta-analyses to expand the evidence. Dance intervention studies consistently improved motor skills, while findings for the other outcomes had a high heterogeneity. Results of this meta-analysis suggest that DMT and dance interventions improve clinical outcomes, cognitive outcomes, and (psycho-)motor outcomes. The high variability of results, especially in the dance cluster, needs further attention. Moreover, this study contributes initial findings that DMT and dance interventions have persistent long-term effects. These encouraging results are limited by methodological shortcomings of the primary studies. Further research is needed that expands on the evidence of effects of DMT and dance interventions on health-related psychological outcomes.

Author Contributions

SK conceived, planned, co-wrote and revised the study and supervised the Master's (RR, KT) and doctoral level students (LM, JB). LM and KT did the systematic literature search. LM, KT, and SK did the hand search. RR and AB planned and implemented the methodological approach, AB supervised the methodology of the study. KT, JB, and RR organized the results. RR analyzed the results and wrote the first draft. All authors contributed to the paper and revised it into its final version.

Conflict of Interest Statement

The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.

Acknowledgments

We would like to thank Simea Schönenberger, Friederike Klodwig, and Katrin Sachau for helping to extract data from the primary studies as part of their DMT student elective hours. We would like to thank all colleagues who have supported us to find relevant literature, and all authors of primary studies who helped to clarify data issues. Thanks to all participants of the primary studies for completing the scales and driving research on embodied interventions further.

1 This term includes the practice of dance movement psychotherapy (UK terminology) and dance/movement therapy (US terminology).

2 For a list of abbreviations, see Appendix .

3 Creative Arts Therapies (European term: Arts Therapies; Karkou and Sanderson, 2006 ) consist mainly of art therapy, music therapy, dance movement therapy, drama therapy, and poetry therapy/expressive writing.

References marked with an asterisk indicate studies that are included in the meta-analysis; references marked with a circle were screened but excluded studies.

Funding. The study was conducted by the Research Institute for Creative Arts Therapies (RIArT) at Alanus University funded by the Software AG Foundation in Darmstadt, in colaboration with the University of Jena, Drexel University, and SRH University Heidelberg. The Faculty of Therapy Sciences at SRH University Heidelberg funded the publication.

Supplementary Material

The Supplementary Material for this article can be found online at: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2019.01806/full#supplementary-material

• ° Alotaibi A. Karkou V. van Der Linden M. L. Irvine L. M. C (2017). Movement therapy programme with children with mild learning difficulties in primary schools in Saudi Arabia: links between motion and emotion, in The Oxford Handbook of Dance and Wellbeing , eds Karkou V., Oliver S., Lycouris S. (Edinburgh: Queen Margaret University, 479–492. [ Google Scholar ]
• ° Alrazain B., Zubala A., Karkou V. (2018). Movement-based arts therapy for children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, in Arts Therapies in the Treatment of Depression , eds Zubala A., Karkou V. (London: Routledge, 84–100. [ Google Scholar ]
• ° Burzynska A. Z., Jiao Y., Knecht A. M., Fanning J., Awick E. A., Chen T., et al. (2017). White matter integrity declined over 6-months, but dance intervention improved integrity of the Fornix of older adults . Front. Aging Neurosci. 9 :59 10.3389/fnagi.2017.00059 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• ° Cross K., Flores R., Butterfield J., Blackman M., Lee S. (2012). The effect of passive listening versus active observation of music and dance performances on memory recognition and mild to moderate depression in cognitively impaired older adults . Psychol. Rep. 111 , 413–423. 10.2466/10.02.13.PR0.111.5.413-423 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• ° Koch S., Kelbel J., Kolter A., Sattel H., Fuchs T. (2017). (Dis)embodiment in schizophrenia: effects of mirroring of self-experience, empathy and wellbeing, in Oxford Handbook Dance Wellbeing , eds Karkou V., Oliver S., Lycouris S. (London, UK: Routledge; ), 863–882. [ Google Scholar ]
• ° Lewis C., Annett L. E., Davenport S., Hall A. A., Lovatt P. (2014). Mood changes following social dance sessions in people with Parkinson's disease . J. Health Psychol. 21 , 483–492. 10.1177/1359105314529681 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• ° Mateos-Moreno D., Atencia-Doña L. (2013). Effect of a combined dance/movement and music therapy on young adults diagnosed with severe autism . Arts Psychother. 40 , 465–472. 10.1016/j.aip.2013.09.004 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• ° Meyer DeMott M. A., Jakobsen M., Wentzel-Larsen T., Heir T. (2017). A controlled early group intervention study for unaccompanied minors: can expressive arts alleviate symptoms of trauma and enhance life satisfaction? Scand. J. Psychol. 58 , 510–518. 10.1111/sjop.12395 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• ° Savill M., Orfanos S., Bentall R., Reininghaus U., Wykes T., Priebe S. (2017). The impact of gender on treatment effectiveness of body psychotherapy for negative symptoms of schizophrenia: a secondary analysis of the NESS trial data . Psychiatry Res. 247 , 73–78. 10.1016/j.psychres.2016.11.020 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• ° Vancea F. (2013). Unifying personal development through dance, movement and the increase of the emotional intelligence level . J. Exp. Psychother. Psihoter. Exp. 16 :3. [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Abraham A., Hart A., Andrade I., Hackney M. E. (2018). Dynamic neuro-cognitive imagery improves mental imagery ability, disease severity, and motor and cognitive functions in people with Parkinson's disease . Neural Plast. 2018 :6168507. 10.1155/2018/6168507 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Adam D., Ramli A., Shahar S. (2016). Effectiveness of a combined dance and relaxation intervention on reducing anxiety and depression and improving quality of life among the cognitively impaired elderly . Sultan Qaboos Univ. Med. J. 16 , 47–53. 10.18295/squmj.2016.16.01.009 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• ADTA American Dance Therapy Association (2018). Available online at: www.adta.org
• Aguiar L. P. C., Da Rocha P. A., Morris M. (2016). Therapeutic dancing for Parkinson's disease . Int. J. Gerontol . 10 , 64–70. 10.1016/j.ijge.2016.02.002 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Aithal S., Karkou V. (2018). Backing the backbones—a feasibility study of effectiveness of dance movement psychotherapy on parenting stress in caregivers of children with Autism Spectrum Disorders . Arts Psycother. 64 , 69–76. 10.1016/j.aip.2019.04.003 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Allet L., Müller-Pinget S., Punt I., Edelsten C., Ballif A., Golay A., et al.. (2017). Dance therapy combined with patient education improves quality of life of persons with obesity: a pilot feasibility study for a randomised controlled trial . Obes. Res. Clin. Pract. 11 , 79–87. 10.1016/j.orcp.2016.03.005 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Archer S., Buxton S., Sheffield D. (2015). The effect of creative psychological interventions on psychological outcomes for adult cancer patients: a systematic review of randomised controlled trials . Psychooncology 24 , 1–10. 10.1002/pon.3607 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Aweto H. A., Owoeye O. B., Akinbo S. R., Onabajo A. A. (2012). Effects of dance movement therapy on selected cardiovascular parameters and estimated maximum oxygen consumption in hypertensive patients . Nig. Q. J. Hosp. Med. 22 , 125–129. [ PubMed ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Baptista A. S., Villela A. L., Jones A., Natour J. (2012). Effectiveness of dance in patients with fibromyalgia: a randomized, single-blind, controlled study . Clin. Exp. Rheumatol. 30 , 18–23. [ PubMed ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Barba H., Knill M., Fuchs M. (1995). Minstrels of Soul: Intermodal Expressive Therapy . Toronto, ON: Palmerston Press. [ Google Scholar ]
• Beelmann A., Heinrichs N. (2015). Evidence based psychotherapy, in International Encyclopedia of Social and Behavioral Sciences , 2nd Ed, Vol. 8. ed Wright J. D. (Oxford: Elsevier, 344–350. [ Google Scholar ]
• Belardinelli R., Lacalaprice F., Ventrella C., Volpe L., Faccenda E. (2008). Waltz-dancing in patients with chronic heart failure: a new form of exercise training . Circ. Heart Fail. 1 , 107–114. 10.1161/CIRCHEARTFAILURE.108.765727 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Berrol C. F. (2000). The spectrum of research options in dance/movement therapy . Am. J. Dance Ther. 22 , 29–46. 10.1023/A:1005518409716 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Biber K. (2016). The effects of folk dance training on 5-6 years children's physical and social development . J. Educ. Train. Stud. 4 , 213–226. 10.11114/jets.v4i11.1820 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Boehm K., Cramer H., Staroszynski T., Ostermann T. (2014). Arts therapies for anxiety, depression, and quality of life in breast cancer patients: a systematic review and meta-analysis . Evid. Based Complement. Altern. Med. 2014 :103297. 10.1155/2014/103297 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Bohlmeijer E., Prenger R., Taal E., Cuijpers P. (2010). The effects of mindfulness-based stress reduction therapy on mental health of adults with a chronic medical disease: a meta-analysis . J. Psychosom. Res. 68 , 539–544. 10.1016/j.jpsychores.2009.10.005 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Borg W. R. (1993). Applying Educational Research: A Practical Guide . New York, NY: Longman. [ Google Scholar ]
• Bradt J., Goodill S. W., Dileo C. (2011). Dance/movement therapy for improving psychological and physical outcomes in cancer patients . Cochrane Database Syst. Rev . 1 :CD007103. 10.1002/14651858.CD007103.pub2 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Bradt J., Shim M., Goodill S. W. (2015). Dance/movement therapy for improving psychological and physical outcomes in cancer patients . Cochrane Database Syst. Rev . 1 :CD007103. 10.1002/14651858.CD007103.pub3 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Bräuninger I. (2012a). The efficacy of dance movement therapy group on improvement of quality of life: a randomized controlled trial . Arts Psychother. 39 , 296–303. 10.1016/j.aip.2012.03.008 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Bräuninger I. (2012b). Dance movement therapy group intervention in stress treatment: a randomized controlled trial (RCT) . Arts Psychother. 39 , 443–450. 10.1016/j.aip.2012.07.002 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Bräuninger I. (2014). Specific dance movement therapy interventions—which are successful? An intervention and correlation study . Arts Psychother. 41 , 445–457. 10.1016/j.aip.2014.08.002 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Burgess G., Grogan S., Burwitz L. (2006). Effects of a 6-week aerobic dance intervention on body image and physical self-perceptions in adolescent girls . Body Image 3 , 57–66. 10.1016/j.bodyim.2005.10.005 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Caldwell C. (1996). Getting Our Bodies Back . Boulder, CO: Shambala Edition. [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Campion M., Levita L. (2014). Enhancing positive affect and divergent thinking abilities: play some music and dance . J. Posit. Psychol. 9 , 137–145. 10.1080/17439760.2013.848376 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Chiang C. H., Chu C. L., Lee T. C. (2016). Efficacy of caregiver-mediated joint engagement intervention for young children with autism spectrum disorders . Autism 20 , 172–82. 10.1177/1362361315575725 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Chouhan S., Kumar S. (2011). Comparative study between effectiveness of dance movement therapy and progressive relaxation therapy with music for stress management in college students . Indian J. Physiother. Occup. Ther. 5 , 179–182. [ Google Scholar ]
• Christensen J. F., Jola C. (2015). Moving towards ecological validity in empirical aesthetics of dance, in Art, Aesthetics and the Brain . eds Houston J. P., Nadal M., Mora F., Agnati L. F., Cela-Conde C. J. (Oxford: Oxford University Press; ), 223–262. [ Google Scholar ]
• Cohen J. (1988). The effect size, in Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioural Science , 2nd Edition. ed Erlbaum L. (New York, NY: Taylor and Francis Inc, 79–80. [ Google Scholar ]
• Conceição L. S., Neto M. G., do Amaral M. A. S., Martins-Filho P. R. S., Oliveira Carvalho V. (2016). Effect of dance therapy on blood pressure and exercise capacity of individuals with hypertension: a systematic review and meta-analysis . Int. J. Cardiol. 220 , 553–557. 10.1016/j.ijcard.2016.06.182 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Connolly M. K., Quin E., Redding E. (2011). Dance 4 your life: exploring the health and well-being implications of a contemporary dance intervention for female adolescents . Res. Dance Educ. 12 , 53–66. 10.1080/14647893.2011.561306 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Coubard O. A., Duretz S., Lefebvre V., Lapalus P., Ferrufino L. (2011). Practice of contemporary dance improves cognitive flexibility in aging . Front. Aging Neurosci. 3 :13. 10.3389/fnagi.2011.00013 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Cruz R. F., Berrol C. (2012). Dance/Movement Therapists in Action: A Working Guide to Research Options . Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas. [ Google Scholar ]
• Cruz R. F., Sabers D. (1998). Dance/movement therapy is more effective than pre-previously reported . Arts Psychother. 25 , 101–104. [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Cruz-Ferreira A., Marmeleira J., Formigo A., Gomes D., Fernandes J. (2015). Creative dance improves physical fitness and life satisfaction in older women . Res. Aging 37 , 837–855. 10.1177/0164027514568103 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Csikszentmihalyi M., Csikszentmihalyi I. (1975). Beyond Boredom and Anxiety . San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass. [ Google Scholar ]
• De Dreu M. J., van der Wilk A. S. D., Poppe E., Kwakkel G., van Wegen E. E. H. (2012). Rehabilitation, exercise therapy and music in patients with Parkinson's disease: a meta-analysis of the effects of music-based movement therapy on walking ability, balance and quality of life . Parkinsonism Relat. Disord. 18 ( Suppl. 1 ), S114–S119. 10.1016/S1353-8020(11)70036-0 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . De Natale E. R., Paulus K. S., Aiello E., Sanna B., Manca A., Sotgiu G., et al.. (2017). Dance therapy improves motor and cognitive functions in patients with Parkinson's disease . Neurorehabilitation 40 , 141–144. 10.3233/NRE-161399 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Dreeben S. J., Mamberg M. H., Salmon P. (2013). The MBSR body scan in clinical practice . Mindfulness 4 , 394–401. 10.1007/s12671-013-0212-z [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Duberg A., Hagberg L., Sunvisson H., Möller M. (2013). Influencing self-rated health among adolescent girls with dance intervention: a randomized controlled trial . JAMA Pediatr. 167 , 27–31. 10.1001/jamapediatrics.2013.421 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Duim E. L., do Nascimento C. F., da Silva A. (2015). Dance movement therapy as rehabilitation process for women with falls history . Gerontologist 55 :719 10.1093/geront/gnv358.03 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Dunphy K., Baker F. A., Dumaresq E., Carroll-Haskins K., Eickholt J., Ercole M., et al.. (2019). Creative arts interventions to address depression in older adults: a systematic review of outcomes, processes, and mechanisms . Front. Psychol. 9 :2655. 10.3389/fpsyg.2018.02655 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Duval S., Tweedie R. (2000). Trim and fill: a simple funnel-plot-based method of testing and adjusting for publication bias in meta-analysis . Biometrics 56 , 455–463. 10.1111/j.0006-341X.2000.00455.x [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• EADMT European Association Dance Movement Therapy (2018). Available online at: www.eadmt.com
• Feniger-Schaal R., Hart Y., Lotan N., Koren-Karie N., Noy L. (2018). The body speaks: using the mirror game to link attachment and non-verbal behavior . Front. Psychol. 9 :1560. 10.3389/fpsyg.2018.01560 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Fjorback L. O., Arendt M., Ørnbøl E., Fink P., Walach H. (2011). Mindfulness-based stress reduction and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy—a systematic review of randomized controlled trials . Acta Psychiatr. Scand. 124 , 102–119. 10.1111/j.1600-0447.2011.01704.x [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Gomes Neto M., Menezes M. A., Carvalho V. O. (2014). Dance therapy in patients with chronic heart failure: a systematic review and a meta-analysis . Clin. Rehabil. 28 , 1172–1179. 10.1177/0269215514534089 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Goodill S. (2005). An Introduction to Medical Dance/Movement Therapy: Health Care in Motion . London; Philadelphia: Jessica Kingsley Publishers. [ Google Scholar ]
• Grainge M. (2015). Excluding Small Studies From a Systematic Review or Metaanalysis . Available online at: https://skin.cochrane.org/sites/skin.cochrane.org/files/public/uploads/CSG-COUSIN_March%202015_M%20Grainge.pdf [accessed January 4, 2019].
• Grawe K., Donati R., Bernauer F. (1994). Psychotherapie im Wandel: von der Konfession zur Profession . Göttingen: Verlag für Psychologie, Hogrefe. [ Google Scholar ]
• Green S. B. (1991). How many subjects does it take to do a regression analysis? Multivariate Behav. Res . 26 , 499–510. 10.1207/s15327906mbr2603_7 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Guerra-Balic M., Barnet-López S., Signo-Miguel S., Pérez-Testor S., Bruna O., Solano L., et al. (2017). Cognitive benefits of a dance movement therapy program in adults with intellectual disabilities . Med. Sci. Sport. Exerc. 49 :75 10.1249/01.mss.0000517033.34425.61 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Guzmán-García A., Hughes J. C., James I. A., Rochester L. (2013). Dancing as a psychosocial intervention in care homes: a systematic review of the literature . Int. J. Geriatr. Psychiatry . 28 , 914–924. 10.1002/gps.3913 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Hackney M. E., Bennett C. G. (2014). Dance therapy for individuals with Parkinson's disease: improving quality of life . J. Park. Restless Legs Syndr. 4 , 17–25. 10.2147/JPRLS.S40042 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Hall M. (2011). Dance/movement therapy in inpatient hematological cancer treatment in creative arts therapies (Theses) . Columbia College, Chicago, IL, United States, 5. [ Google Scholar ]
• Harris R. J. (1985). A Primer of Multivariate Statistics ,2nd Edn. New York, NY: Academic Press. [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Hashimoto H., Takabatake S., Miyaguchi H., Nakanishi H., Naitou Y. (2015). Effects of dance on motor functions, cognitive functions, and mental symptoms of Parkinson's disease: a quasi-randomized pilot trial . Complement. Ther. Med. 23 , 210–219. 10.1016/j.ctim.2015.01.010 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Hayes A. F. (2013). Introduction to Mediation, Moderation, and Conditional Process Analysis: A Regression-Based Approach . New York, NY: Guilford Press. [ Google Scholar ]
• Hedges L. V., Olkin I. (1985). Statistical Methods for Meta-Analysis . San Diego, CA: Academic Press. [ Google Scholar ]
• Hervey L. W. (2000). Artistic Inquiry in Dance/Movement Therapy: Creative Research Alternatives . Springfield, IL: Charles C Thomas Publisher. [ Google Scholar ]
• Higgins J. P., Green S. (2008). Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions: Cochrane Book Series . West Sussex, UK: Wiley. [ Google Scholar ]
• Higgins J. P., Thompson S. G., Deeks J. J., Altman D. G. (2003). Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses . BMJ 327 :557. 10.1136/bmj.327.7414.557 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Higgins J. P. T., Altman D. G., Gøtzsche P. C., Jüni P., Moher D., Oxman A. D., et al.. (2011). The Cochrane Collaboration's tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trials . BMJ 343 :d5928. 10.1136/bmj.d5928 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Hildebrandt M., Koch S., Fuchs T. (2016). We dance and find each other: effects of dance/movement therapy on negative symptoms in autism spectrum disorder . Behav. Sci. 6 :24 10.3390/bs6040024 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Ho R. T. H., Fong T. C. T., Cheung I. K. M., Yip P. S. F., Luk M. Y. (2016a). Effects of a short-term dance movement therapy program on symptoms and stress in patients with breast cancer undergoing radiotherapy: a randomized, controlled, single-blind trial . J. Pain Symptom Manage. 51 , 824–831. 10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2015.12.332 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Ho R. T. H., Lo P. H. Y., Luk M. Y. (2016b). A good time to dance? A mixed-methods approach of the effects of dance movement therapy for breast cancer patients during and after radiotherapy . Cancer Nurs. 39 , 32–41. 10.1097/NCC.0000000000000237 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Hwang H. H., Choi Y. J., Kim B. R. (2010). The effects of dance therapy program on the cognitive function and memory of movement of elderly with dementia . Korean J. Phys. Educ. 49 , 373–382. [ Google Scholar ]
• Jakobsen M., DeMott M. A. M., Wentzel-Larsen T., Heir T. (2017). The impact of the asylum process on mental health: a longitudinal study of unaccompanied refugee minors in Norway . BMJ Open 7 :e015157. 10.1136/bmjopen-2016-015157 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Jeong Y. J., Hong S. C., Myeong S. L., Park M. C., Kim Y. K., Suh C. M. (2005). Dance movement therapy improves emotional responses and modulates neurohormones in adolescents with mild depression . Int. J. Neurosci . 115 , 1711–1720. 10.1080/00207450590958574 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Jola C. (2013). Do you feel the same way too? in Touching and Being Touched: Kinesthesia and Empathy in Dance and Movement (Berlin: De Gruyter; ), 181–210. [ Google Scholar ]
• Jola C., Calmeiro L. (2017). The dancing queen: explanatory mechanisms of the ‘feel-good effect’ in dance, in The Oxford Handbook of Dance and Wellbeing . eds Karkou V., Oliver S., Lykouris S. (London: Oxford University Press; ), 13–23. [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Kaltsatou A., Kouidi E., Fountoulakis K., Sipka C., Theochari V., Kandylis D., et al.. (2015). Effects of exercise training with traditional dancing on functional capacity and quality of life in patients with schizophrenia: a randomized controlled study . Clin. Rehabil. 29 , 882–891. 10.1177/0269215514564085 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Kaltsatou A., Mameletzi D., Douka S. (2011). Physical and psychological benefits of a 24-week traditional dance program in breast cancer survivors . J. Bodyw. Mov. Ther. 15 , 162–167. 10.1016/j.jbmt.2010.03.002 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Karkou V., Meekums B. (2017). Dance movement therapy for dementia . Cochrane Database Syst. Rev . CD011022. 10.1002/14651858.CD011022.pub2 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Karkou V., Sanderson P. (2006). Arts Therapies: A Research-Based Map of the Field . Amsterdam: Elsevier. [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Kattenstroth J. C., Kalisch T., Holt S., Tegenthoff M., Dinse H. R. (2013). Six months of dance intervention enhances postural, sensorimotor, and cognitive performance in elderly without affecting cardio-respiratory functions . Front. Aging Neurosci. 5 :5. 10.3389/fnagi.2013.00005 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Kazdin A. E. (2007). Mediators and mechanism of change in psychotherapy research . Ann. Rev. of Clin. Psych. 3 , 1–27. 10.1146/annurev.clinpsy.3.022806.091432 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Kiepe M. S., Stöckigt B., Keil T. (2012). Effects of dance therapy and ballroom dances on physical and mental illnesses: a systematic review . Arts Psychother. 39 , 404–411. 10.1016/j.aip.2012.06.001 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Koch S. C. (2011). Embodiment. Der Einfluss von Eigenbewegung auf Affekt, Einstellung und Kognition . Berlin: Logos. [ Google Scholar ]
• Koch S. C. (2017). Arts and health: active factors and a theory framework of embodied aesthetics . Arts Psychother. 54 , 85–91. 10.1016/j.aip.2017.02.002 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Koch S. C. (2019). Indications and contraindications in dance movement therapy. An inductive approach from practitioners' experience . J. Arts Ther. 1. [ Google Scholar ]
• Koch S. C., Kunz T., Lykou S., Cruz R. (2014). Effects of dance movement therapy and dance on health-related psychological outcomes: a meta-analysis . Arts Psychother. 41 , 46–64. 10.1016/j.aip.2013.10.004 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Koch S. C., Mehl L., Sobanski E., Sieber M., Fuchs T. (2015a). Fixing the mirrors: a feasibility study of the effects of dance movement therapy on young adults with autism spectrum . Autism 19 , 338–350. 10.1177/1362361314522353 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Koch S. C., Morlinghaus K., Fuchs T. (2007). The joy dance: specific effects of a single dance intervention on psychiatric patients with depression . Arts Psychother. 34 , 340–349. 10.1016/j.aip.2007.07.001 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Koch S. C., Ostermann T., Steinhage A., Kende P., Haller K., Chyle F. (2015b). Breaking barriers: evaluating an arts-based emotion regulation training in prison . Arts Psychother. 42 , 41–49. 10.1016/j.aip.2014.10.008 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Koch S. C., Wirtz G., Harter C., Weisbrod M., Winkler F., Pröger A., et al. (2019). Embodied self in trauma and self-harm: effects of flamenco therapy on traumatized in-patients . A pilot study. J. Loss Trauma 24 , 441–459. 10.1080/15325024.2018.1507472 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Koehne S., Behrends A., Fairhurst M. T., Dziobek I. (2016). Fostering social cognition through an imitation- and synchronization-based dance/movement intervention in adults with autism spectrum disorder: a controlled proof-of-concept study . Psychother. Psychosom. 85 , 27–35. 10.1159/000441111 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Kraemer H. C., Thiemann S. (1987). How Many Subjects? Statistical Power Analysis in Research , 2nd Edn. London: Sage Publications. [ Google Scholar ]
• Lange G., Hartmann N., Eberhard-Kaechele M., Koch S. C. (in press). Arts-based research: aesthetic answering as a method of embodied analysis in the context of creative arts therapies, in Embodied Research Methods . ed Tantia J. (New York, NY: Routledge; ). [ Google Scholar ]
• Leavy P. (2017). Handbook of Arts-Based Research. Guilford Publications . Available online at: https://books.google.de/books?id=TtpLMQAACAAJ [accessed January 4, 2019].
• * . Lee H.-J., Jang S.-H., Lee S.-Y., Hwang K.-S. (2015). Effectiveness of dance/movement therapy on affect and psychotic symptoms in patients with schizophrenia . Arts Psychother. 45 , 64–68. 10.1016/j.aip.2015.07.003 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Levine B., Land H. M. (2016). A meta-synthesis of qualitative findings about dance/movement therapy for individuals with trauma . Qual. Health Res. 26 , 330–344. 10.1177/1049732315589920 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Lipsey M. W., Wilson D. B. (2001). Practical Meta-Analysis . Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. [ Google Scholar ]
• Loetzke D., Ostermann T., Büssing A. (2015). Argentine tango in Parkinson disease—a systematic review and meta-analysis . BMC Neurol. 15 :1 10.1186/s12883-015-0484-0 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Martin L., Oepen R., Bauer K., Nottensteiner A., Mergheim K., Gruber H., et al.. (2018). Creative arts interventions for stress management and prevention—a systematic review . Behav. Sci. 8 :2. 10.3390/bs8020028 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Martin L. A. L., Koch S. C., Hirjak D., Fuchs T. (2016). Overcoming disembodiment: the effect of movement therapy on negative symptoms in schizophrenia—a multicenter randomized controlled trial . Front. Psychol. 7 :483. 10.3389/fpsyg.2016.00483 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Maul A. (2013). Method effects and the meaning of measurement . Front. Psychol . 4 :169. 10.3389/fpsyg.2013.00169 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• McCambridge J., Witton J., Elbourne D. R. (2014). Systematic review of the Hawthorne effect: new concepts are needed to study research participation effects . J. Clin. Epidemiol. 67 , 267–277. 10.1016/j.jclinepi.2013.08.015 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• McGarry L. M., Russo F. A. (2011). Mirroring in dance/movement therapy: potential mechanisms behind empathy enhancement . Arts Psychother. 38 , 178–184. 10.1016/j.aip.2011.04.005 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• McNiff S. (1993). The authority of experience . Arts Psychother. 20 , 3–9. 10.1016/0197-4556(93)90028-Z [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Meekums B., Karkou V., Nelson E. A. (2015). Dance movement therapy for depression . Cochrane Database Syst. Rev. 39 , 126–133. 10.1002/14651858.CD009895.pub2 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Meric O., Ilhan A. (2016). Does 12-week Latin dance training affect the self-confidence of the university students? J. Educ. Learn. 5 , 159–164. 10.5539/jel.v5n4p159 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Michalak J., Heidenreich T., Meibert P., Schulte D. J. (2008). Mindfulness predicts relapse/recurrence in major depressive disorder after mindfulness-based cognitive therapy . Nerv. Ment. Dis. 196 , 630–633. 10.1097/NMD.0b013e31817d0546 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Murrock C. J., Madigan E. (2008). Self-efficacy and social support as mediators between culturally specific dance and lifestyle physical activity . Res. Theory Nurs. Pract. 22 , 192–204. 10.1891/1541-6577.22.3.192 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Palo-Bengtsson L., Ekman S. L. (1997). Social dancing in the care of persons with dementia in a nursing home setting: a phenomenological study . Sch. Inq. Nurs. Pract. 11 , 101–118. [ PubMed ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Palo-Bengtsson L., Winblad B., Ekman S. L. (1998). Social dancing: a way to support intellectual, emotional and motor functions in persons with dementia . J. Psychiatr. Ment. Health Nurs . 5 , 545–554. 10.1046/j.1365-2850.1998.560545.x [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Panagiotopoulou E. (2018). Dance therapy and the public school: the development of social and emotional skills of high school students in Greece . Arts Psychother. 59 , 25–33. 10.1016/j.aip.2017.11.003 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Peters H. J. (2012). Dance/dance movement therapy and general wellbeing, depression, and anxiety: A meta-analysis (Doctoral dissertation: ). University of Tasmania. [ Google Scholar ]
• Pilates J. H., Miller W. J. (1945). Return to Life Through Contrology (Reprint 1998) . New York, NY: Presentation Dynamics Inc. [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Pinniger R., Brown R. F., Thorsteinsson E. B., McKinley P. (2012). Argentine tango dance compared to mindfulness meditation and a waiting-list control: a randomised trial for treating depression . Complement. Ther. Med. 20 , 377–384. 10.1016/j.ctim.2012.07.003 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Pinniger R., Thorsteinsson E. B., Brown R. F., McKinley P. (2013). Tango dance can reduce distress and insomnia in people with self-referred affective symptoms . Am. J. Dance Ther. 35 , 60–77. 10.1007/s10465-012-9141-y [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Pohlmann V., Koch S. C., Fuchs T. (2017). Changes in well-being of schizophrenic patients after movement therapy: results of a multicenter RCT study, in Arts Therapies and New Challenges in Psychiatry (London: Routledge; ), 114–139. [ Google Scholar ]
• Price C., Smith-DiJulio K. (2016). Interoceptive awareness is important for relapse prevention: perceptions of women who received mindful body-awareness in substance use disorder treatment . J. Addict. Nurs. 27 , 32–38. 10.1097/JAN.0000000000000109 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Priebe S., Savill M., Wykes T., Bentall R. P., Reininghaus U., Lauber C., et al.. (2016). Effectiveness of group body psychotherapy for negative symptoms of schizophrenia: multicentre randomised controlled trial . Br. J. Psychiatry . 209 , 54–61. 10.1192/bjp.bp.115.171397 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Pylvänäinen P. M., Muotka J. S., Lappalainen R. (2015). A dance movement therapy group for depressed adult patients in a psychiatric outpatient clinic: effects of the treatment . Front. Psychol. 6 :980. 10.3389/fpsyg.2015.00980 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Quiroga Murcia C., Bongard S., Kreutz G. (2009). Emotional and neurohumoral responses to dancing tango argentino: the effects of music and partner . Music Med. 1 , 14–21. 10.1177/1943862109335064 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Ree M. J., Craigie M. A. (2007). Outcomes following mindfulness-based cognitive therapy in a heterogeneous sample of adult outpatients . Behav. Change . 24 , 70–86. 10.1375/bech.24.2.70 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Rios Romenets S., Anang J., Fereshtehnejad S. M., Pelletier A., Postuma R. (2015). Tango for treatment of motor and non-motor manifestations in Parkinson's disease: a randomized control study . Complement. Ther. Med. 23 , 175–184. 10.1016/j.ctim.2015.01.015 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Ritter M., Graff Low K. (1996). Effects of dance/movement therapy: a meta-analysis . Arts Psychother. 23 , 249–260. 10.1016/0197-4556(96)00027-5 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Rodrigues-Krause J., Farinha J. B., Krause M., Reischak-Oliveira Á. (2016). Effects of dance interventions on cardiovascular risk with ageing: systematic review and meta-analysis . Complement. Ther. Med. 29 , 16–28. 10.1016/j.ctim.2016.09.004 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Roethlisberger F. J., Dickson W. J. (1964). Management and the Worker: An Account of a Research Program Conducted by the Western Electric Company, Hawthorne Works, Chicago, by FJ Roethlisberger and William J. Dickson, With the Assistance and Collaboration of Harold A. Wright . Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. [ Google Scholar ]
• Röhricht F., Papadopoulos N., Priebe S. (2013). An exploratory randomized controlled trial of body psychotherapy for patients with chronic depression . J. Affect. Disord. 151 , 85–91. 10.1016/j.jad.2013.05.056 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Röhricht F., Priebe S. (2006). Effect of body-oriented psychological therapy on negative symptoms in schizophrenia: a randomized controlled trial . Psychol. Med. 36 , 669–678. 10.1017/S0033291706007161 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Rosenthal R. (1966). Experimenter Effects in Behavioral Research . East Norwalk, CT: Appleton-Century-Crofts. [ Google Scholar ]
• Rosenthal R. (1979). The file drawer problem and tolerance for null results . Psychol. Bull . 86 , 638–641. 10.1037/0033-2909.86.3.638 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Rutan J. S., Stone W. N. (2001). Psychodynamic Group Psychotherapy . 3rd Edn. New York, NY: Guilford Press. [ Google Scholar ]
• Sackett D. L., Straus S. E., Richardson S. W., Rosenberg W., Haynes B. R. (2000). Evidence-Based Medicine: How to Practice and Teach EBM . London: Churchill Livingstone. [ Google Scholar ]
• Sandel S. L., Chaiklin S., Lohn A. (1993). Foundations of Dance Movement Therapy: The Life and Work of Marian Chace. Marian Chace Memorial Fund of the American Dance Therapy Association. Columbia: American Dance Therapy Association. [ Google Scholar ]
• Schmais C. (1985). Healing processes in group dance therapy . Am. J. Dance Ther . 8 , 17–36. 10.1007/BF02251439 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Schmais C. (1998). Understanding the dance/movement therapy group . Am. J. Dance Ther. 20 , 23–35. 10.1023/A:1022845708143 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Serrano-Guzmán M., Valenza-Peña C. M., Serrano-Guzmán C., Aguilar-Ferrándiz E., Valenza-Demet G., Villaverde-Gutiérrez C. (2016). Effects of a dance therapy programme on quality of life, sleep and blood pressure in middle-aged women: a randomised controlled trial . Med. Clín. 147 , 334–339. 10.1016/j.medcle.2016.11.016 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Shanahan J., Morris M. E., Bhriain O. N., Saunders J., Clifford A. M. (2015). Dance for people with Parkinson's disease: what is the evidence telling us? Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil . 96 , 141–153. 10.1016/j.apmr.2014.08.017 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Sharp K., Hewitt J. (2014). Dance as an intervention for people with Parkinson's disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis . Neurosci. Biobehav. Rev . 47 , 445–456. 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2014.09.009 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Sharpe D. (1997). Of apples and oranges, file drawers and garbage: why validity issues in meta-analysis will not go away . Clin. Psychol. Rev. 17 , 881–901. 10.1016/S0272-7358(97)00056-1 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Stück M., Villegas A. (2017). Evidence-based BIODANZA programmes for children (TANZPRO-Biodanza) in schools and kinder-gartens, in The Oxford Handbook of Dance and Wellbeing , 75–96. [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Sturm I., Baak J., Storek B., Traore A., Thuss-Patience P. (2014). Effect of dance on cancer-related fatigue and quality of life . Support. Care Cancer 22 , 2241–2249. 10.1007/s00520-014-2181-8 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Teasdale J. D., Segal Z. V., Williams J. M., Ridgeway V. A., Soulsby J. M., Lau M. A. (2000). Prevention of relapse/recurrence in major depression by mindfulness-based cognitive therapy . J. Consult. Clin. Psychol. 68 , 615–623. 10.1037/0022-006X.68.4.615 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Teixeira-Machado L., Azevedo-Santos I., De Santana J. M. (2017). Dance improves functionality and psychosocial adjustment in cerebral palsy: a randomized controlled clinical trial . Am. J. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 96 , 424–429. 10.1097/PHM.0000000000000646 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Van Westrhenen N., Fritz E., Vermeer A., Boelen P., Kleber R. (2019). Creative arts in psychotherapy for traumatized children in South Africa: an evaluation study . PLoS ONE 14 :e0210857. 10.1371/journal.pone.0210857 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Vankova H., Holmerova I., Machacova K., Volicer L., Veleta P., Celko A. M. (2014). The effect of dance on depressive symptoms in nursing home residents . J. Am. Med. Dir. Assoc. 15 , 582–587. 10.1016/j.jamda.2014.04.013 [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Ventura M. I., Barnes D. E., Ross J. M., Lanni K. E., Sigvardt K. A., Disbrow E. A. (2016). A pilot study to evaluate multi-dimensional effects of dance for people with Parkinson's disease . Contemp. Clin. Trials 51 , 50–55. 10.1016/j.cct.2016.10.001 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Volpe D., Signorini M., Marchetto A., Lynch T., Morris M. E. (2013). A comparison of Irish set dancing and exercises for people with Parkinson's disease: a phase II feasibility study . BMC Geriatr. 13 :54. 10.1186/1471-2318-13-54 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Wampold B. E. (2015). How important are the common factors in psychotherapy? An update. World Psychiatry 14 , 270–277. 10.1002/wps.20238 [ PMC free article ] [ PubMed ] [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Wampold B. E., Irmel Z. E. (2015). The Great Psychotherapy Debate: The Evidence for What Makes Psychotherapy Work . 2nd EdN. New York, NY: Routledge. [ Google Scholar ]
• Wengrower H., Chaiklin S. (2008). The Art and Science of Dance/Movement Therapy: Life is Dance . New York, NY: Routledge. [ Google Scholar ]
• * . Wiedenhofer S., Koch S. C. (2017). Active factors in dance/movement therapy: specifying health effects of non-goal-orientation in movement . Arts Psychother. 52 , 10–23. 10.1016/j.aip.2016.09.004 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Wilson D. B. (2005). Meta-Analysis Macros for SAS, SPSS, and Stata . Available online at: https://mason.gmu.edu/%7Edwilsonb/ma.html [accessed January 4, 2019].
• Xiong L.i M., Li Q. (2009). Influence of dance therapy of self-efficacy and rehabilitation of patients with depression . Chin. Nurs. Res. 23 , 3138–3139. 10.3969/j.issn.1009-6493.2009.34.015 [ CrossRef ] [ Google Scholar ]
• Yalom I. D. (1985). The Theory and Practice of Group Psychotherapy . 3rd Edn. New York, NY: Basic Books. [ Google Scholar ]

Designing Dance into Qualitative Research

• First Online: 23 January 2020

Cite this chapter

• Claus Springborg 5 , 6  

Part of the book series: Palgrave Studies in Business, Arts and Humanities ((PSBAH))

1426 Accesses

1 Citations

1 Altmetric

Dancers are increasingly seeing their art as a form of research. This is reflected in the development of new techniques, dance notation, and ever-expanding choices of topics that dancers deal with through their performances. Consequently, dance has become a treasure chest for researchers. In this chapter, I present a range of ideas for how elements from the world of dance can be adopted by researchers in business, management, and humanities. Adopting such elements from the world of dance is particularly useful when studying unconscious, affective, and aesthetic aspects of organisational life. For inspiration, I have included four different research designs drawing on dance. However, the possibilities are endless, and the reader is encouraged to be creative.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this chapter

• Available as PDF
• Read on any device
• Instant download
• Own it forever
• Available as EPUB and PDF
• Compact, lightweight edition
• Dispatched in 3 to 5 business days
• Free shipping worldwide - see info
• Durable hardcover edition

Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout

Purchases are for personal use only

Institutional subscriptions

Ackerman, J. M., Nocera, C. C., & Bargh, J. A. (2010). Incidental haptic sensations influence social judgments and decisions. Science, 328 (5987), 1712–1715.

Article   Google Scholar  

Alvesson, M., & Sköldberg, K. (2000). Reflexive methodology (1st ed.). London: Sage.

Google Scholar  

Andrews, K. (2018). Artistry in teaching: A choreographic approach to studying the performative dimensions of teaching. In T. Chemi & X. Du (Eds.), Arts-based methods in education around the world (pp. 15–36). Gistrup: River Publishers.

Argyris, C., & Schön, D. A. (1974). Theory in practice: Increasing professional effectiveness . San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.

Barone, T. E., & Eisner, E. W. (2011). Arts based research . London: Sage.

Barry, D. (1994). Making the invisible visible: Using analogically-based methods to surface unconscious organizational processes. Organization Development Journal, 12 (4), 37–48.

Barry, D., & Hansen, H. (2008). The Sage handbook of new approaches in management and organization . London: Sage.

Book   Google Scholar  

Barsalou, L. W., & Wiemer-Hastings, K. (2005). Situating abstract concepts. In D. Pecher & R. Zwaan (Eds.), Grounding cognition: The role of perception and action in memory, language, and thought (pp. 129–163). New York: Cambridge University Press.

Chapter   Google Scholar  

Berger, P., & Luckmann, T. (1966). The social construction of reality . Garden City, NY: Doubleday.

Biehl-missal, B. (2018). ‘In the mix’: Relational leadership explored through an analysis of techno DJs and dancers. Leadership .

Biehl-missal, B. (2019). Filling the ‘empty space’: Site-specific dance in a techno club. Culture and Organization, 25 (1), 16–31.

Biehl-missal, B., & Springborg, C. (2015). Dance, organization, and leadership. Organizational Aesthetics, 5 (1), 1–10.

Bohannon, J. (2011). Calling all dancing scientists! Science, 333 (6047), 1219.

Bozic, N., & Olsson, B. K. (2013). Culture for radical innovation: What can business learn from creative processes of contemporary dancers? Organizational Aesthetics, 2 (1), 59–83.

Brearley, L. (2002). What is the matter? Journal of Management Inquiry, 11 (3), 298–299.

Chandler, J. (2012). Work as dance. Organization, 19 (6), 865–878.

Cherryholmes, C. H. (1992). Notes on pragmatism and scientific realism. Educational Researcher, 14, 13–17.

Cornell, A. W. (1998). The focusing technique: Confirmatory knowing through the body. In H. Palmer (Ed.), Inner knowing: Consciousness, creativity, insight, and intuition (pp. 159–164). New York: Putnam.

Denhardt, R. B., & Denhardt, J. V. (2006). The dance of leadership: The art of leading in business, government, and society . New York: M. E. Sharpe.

Essén, A., & Winterstorm Värlander, S. (2012). The mutual constitution of sensuous and discursive understanding in scientific practice: An autoethnographic lens on academic writing. Management Learning, 44 (4), 395–423.

Field, A., & Hole, G. (2003). How to design and report experiments . Los Angeles: Sage.

Fineman, S. (2008). Introducing the emotional organization. In S. Fineman (Ed.), The emotional organization: Passions and power (pp. 1–14). Malden: Blackwell.

Grady, J. E. (1997). Foundations of meaning: Primary metaphors and primary scenes . Berkeley: University of California.

Grierson, E., & Brearley, L. (2009). Creative arts research: Narratives of methodologies and practices . Rotterdam, Boston, and Taipei: Sense Publishers.

Himberg, T., Laroche, J., Bigé, R., Buchkowski, M., & Bachrach, A. (2018). Coordinated interpersonal behaviour in collective dance improvisation: The aesthetics of kinaesthetic togetherness. Behavioral Sciences, 8 (23), 1–26.

Hujala, A., Laulainen, S., Kinni, R.-L., Kokkonen, K., & Puttonen, K. (2015). Dancing with the bosses: Creative movement as a method. Organizational Aesthetics, 5 (1), 11–36.

Johnson, R. D. (2013). Dance of leadership: Mastering the art of making a difference using your unique style (2nd ed.). Scotts Valley: Createspace.

Kemmis, S., & Wilkinson, M. (1998). Participatory action research and the study of practice. In B. Atweh, S. Kemmis, & P. Weeks (Eds.), Action research in practice: Partnerships for social justice in education (pp. 21–36). New York: Routledge.

Knowles, J., & Cole, A. (2007). Handbook of the arts in qualitative research: Perspectives, methodologies, examples, and issues (J. Knowles & A. Cole, Eds.). London: Sage.

Kolo, K. (2015). Ode to choreography. Organizational Aesthetics, 5 (1), 37–46.

Kvale, S. (1997). Interview: En introdukton til det kvalitative forskningsinterview . Copenhagen: Hans Reitzels Forlag.

Lakoff, G. (2012). Explaining embodied cognition results. Topics in Cognitive Science, 4 (4), 773–785.

Lakoff, G., & Johnson, M. (1980). Metaphors we live by . Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Lakoff, G., & Johnson, M. (1999). Philosophy in the flesh: The embodied mind and its challenge to Western thought . New York: Basic Books.

Langer, S. (1951). Philosophy in a new key: A study in the symbolism of reason, rite, and art . New York: Mentor Books.

Langer, S. (1962). Philosophical sketches . Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.

Leavy, P. (2009). Method meets art: Arts-based research practice . New York: Guilford Press.

Matzdorf, F. (2015). Demanding followers, empowered leaders: Dance as an “embodied metaphor” for leader-follower-ship. Organizational Aesthetics, 5 (1), 114–130.

McNiff, S. (1998). Art-based research: Shaun McNiff . London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.

McNiff, S. (2004). Research in new keys: An introduction to the ideas and methods of art-based research. Journal of Pedagogy Pluralism and Practice, 9 . https://digitalcommons.lesley.edu/jppp/vol3/iss1/2 .

McNiff, S. (2010). Art-based research. In J. G. Knowles & A. L. Cole (Eds.), Handbook of the arts in qualitative research: Perspectives, methodologies, examples, and issues (pp. 29–40). London: Sage.

Morgan, G. (2006). Images of organizations . Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

Philips, D. C., & Burbules, N. C. (2000). Postpositivism and educational research . Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.

Ropo, A., & Sauer, E. (2008). Dances of leadership: Bridging theory and practice through an aesthetic approach. Journal of Management & Organization, 14, 560–572.

Sandberg, J. (2005). How do we justify knowledge produced within interpretive approaches? Organizational Research Methods, 8 (1), 41–68.

Senge, P., Scharmer, C. O., Jaworski, J., & Flowers, B. S. (2005). Presence: An exploration of profound change in people, organizations, and society . New York: Doubleday.

Springborg, C. (2018). Sensory templates and manager cognition: Art, cognitive science and spiritual practices in management education . London: Palgrave Macmillan.

Springborg, C., & Ladkin, D. (2018). Realising the potential of art-based interventions in managerial learning: Embodied cognition as an explanatory theory. Journal of Business Research, 85, 532–539.

Springborg, C., & Sutherland, I. (2014). Flying blind? In S. S. Taylor & D. Ladkin (Eds.), The physicality of leadership: Gesture, entanglement, taboo, possibilities . Bingley, UK: Emerald Books.

Springborg, C., & Sutherland, I. (2015). Teaching MBAs aesthetic agency through dance. Organizational Aesthetics, 5 (1), 94–113.

Taylor, S. S. (2002). Overcoming aesthetic muteness: Researching organizational members’ aesthetic experience. Human Relations, 55 (7), 821–840.

Taylor, S. S., & Ladkin, D. (2009). Understanding arts-based methods in managerial development. Academy of Management Learning & Education, 8 (1), 55–69.

Taylor, S. S., & Statler, M. (2014). Material matters: Increasing emotional engagement in learning. Journal of Management Education, 38 (4), 586–607.

Wiemer-Hastings, K., & Xu, X. (2005). Content differences for abstract and concrete concepts. Cognitive Science, 29 (5), 719–736.

Zeitner, D. (2015). Embodied and embodiary leadership: Experiential learning in dance and leadership education. Organizational Aesthetics, 5 (1), 167–187.

Download references

Author information

Authors and affiliations.

Copenhagen Business School, Frederiksberg, Denmark

Claus Springborg

CoCreation.dk, Frederiksberg, Denmark

You can also search for this author in PubMed   Google Scholar

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Claus Springborg .

Editor information

Editors and affiliations.

School of Business, University of Leicester, Leicester, UK

Bristol Business School, University of the West of England, Bristol, UK

Harriet Shortt

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

Copyright information

© 2020 The Author(s)

About this chapter

Springborg, C. (2020). Designing Dance into Qualitative Research. In: Ward, J., Shortt, H. (eds) Using Arts-based Research Methods. Palgrave Studies in Business, Arts and Humanities. Palgrave Macmillan, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-33069-9_3

Download citation

DOI : https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-33069-9_3

Published : 23 January 2020

Publisher Name : Palgrave Macmillan, Cham

Print ISBN : 978-3-030-33068-2

Online ISBN : 978-3-030-33069-9

eBook Packages : Business and Management Business and Management (R0)

Share this chapter

Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:

Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article.

Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative

• Publish with us

Policies and ethics

• Find a journal
• Track your research

• Skip to search box
• Skip to main content

Princeton University Library

Dance: a guide to research and resources.

• Introduction
• Dance Encyclopedias & Resources

Key Dance Periodicals (Print or Online)

Dance periodical databases (citations & full text), music periodical databases with significant dance coverage, subject search links for dance & ballet periodicals.

• Streaming Dance Resources
• Dance Companies & Organizations
• Archives & Collections
• American Journal of Dance Therapy
• Dance Chronicle Publishes research on dance and seeks to expand the constituencies, methodologies, and theoretical frameworks represented within the field of dance studies.
• Dance Magazine First published in June 1927 as The American Dancer. Dance Magazine has multiple sister publications, including Pointe, Dance Spirit, Dance Teacher, Dance 212, and DanceU101.
• Dance Research Journal Includes scholarly articles on dance history, theory, pedagogy, politics, science, ethnography, and intersections with cultural, gender, critical race, and diasporic studies. Published 3 times a year by the Congress on Research in Dance.
• Dance Research: The Journal of the Society for Dance Research Covers dance worldwide both from a historical and contemporary perspecive, engaging with current debates on dance and across cognate disciplines with dance at the centre of inquiry.
• Journal of Dance Education The official publication of the National Dance Education Organization.
• Performing Arts Periodicals Database This link opens in a new window Comprehensive coverage of the performing arts, including dance, film, television, drama, theater, stagecraft, musical theater, broadcast arts, comedy, opera, and more. IIPA indexes more than 210 periodicals. Full text is available from 1998 to the present; citations to articles are indexed back to 1864. Formerly known as International Index to the Performing Arts Full Text.
• International Bibliography of Theatre & Dance with Full Text This link opens in a new window Provides extensive full-text of articles, reviews, & other content from many leading, primarily English-language journals & magazines in theater, dance, & the performing arts (1995+). Also offers citations, abstracts, & some full text for articles, books, book chapters, & dissertations back to 1982. Additional selective content dates back to 1929.
• RILM Abstracts of Music Literature with Full Text This link opens in a new window Covers all aspects of music, including historical musicology, ethnomusicology, instruments and voice, dance, and music therapy. If related to music, works in other fields, such as literature, dramatic arts, visual arts, anthropology, sociology, philosophy and physics are included. 1967+
• Dance periodicals--English language
• Dance periodicals--all titles
• Dance periodicals--online
• Ballet periodicals--English language
• Ballet periodicals--all titles
• Ballet periodicals--online

These prefabricated searches of the Princeton University Library catalog capture select groups of journal titles (including annuals) by subject terms dance or ballet. The default sort is alphabetical by title. After clicking and retrieving the result set, you can further refine the results by the search limits in the left sidebar (date range, language, etc.) as well as re-sort the list by other options. You can also click the back-up button to view the original catalog search and design your own (changing the geographical area, language, etc.).

Note: there is some overlap between the result sets for subject searches on dance or ballet (some cataloging records include both keywords). But a number of journal titles have only one or the other subject descriptor depending upon the focus of the journal.

• << Previous: Dance Encyclopedias & Resources
• Next: Streaming Dance Resources >>
• Last Updated: Mar 18, 2024 1:11 PM
• URL: https://libguides.princeton.edu/dance

Academia.edu no longer supports Internet Explorer.

To browse Academia.edu and the wider internet faster and more securely, please take a few seconds to  upgrade your browser .

Enter the email address you signed up with and we'll email you a reset link.

• We're Hiring!
• Help Center

Dance as Art, Theatre, and Practice: Somaesthetic Perspectives

2019, Midwest Studies in Philosophy, XLIV

Related Papers

Dance as Embodied Aesthetics

Barbara Gail Montero

Dance critics sometimes refer to the "kinesthetic appeal" of movement or to the importance of a critic having a good "kinesthetic sense." Moreover, dancers themselves often refer to the embodied aesthetic qualities of movements: this step feels smooth and languid while the other is sharp and powerful, for example. Philosophers, however, have traditionally confined the aesthetic realm to the visual and aural. What is the kinesthetic sense for the critic? What is it that underlies dancers' comments as to the feeling of their movements? And can the dance critic's and dancer's insights into the embodied aesthetics of movement be defended in light of the traditional view? These are the questions I aim to address in this chapter.

The New Yearbook for Phenomenology and Phenomenological Philosophy: Part I: Phenomenological Perspectives on Aesthetics and Art

Maxine Sheets-Johnstone

The aesthetic unity of dancer and dance is a unique phenomenon in the art world. In exploring the nature and consequences of the aesthetic unity, this chapter first focuses on a dancer's and an audience's experience of dance, pointing out in the process an affective difference and a difference evident in an audience's recognition of technical virtuosity. The chapter then turns to writings of writer and filmmaker Susan Sontag and of eminent choreographer/dancer Merce Cunningham, and to those of Cunningham dancer Carolyn Brown and world-renown choreographer Pina Bausch, all of which describe in different ways the aesthetic unity of dancer and dance, ways that heighten understandings of dance, its uniqueness in the world of art, and its challenges. The well-known ending line from Yeats's poem "Among School Children"-"How can we know the dancer from the dance?"epitomizes just such a range of perspectives. The temporal awareness that runs like an undercurrent through the perspectives centers on the fleeting "nowness" of dance, its existential impermanence, hence the temporal unity of dancer and dance, and the temporality of movement itself, both of which are major factors in the challenge of preserving the art of dance. The chapter shows how this challenge may explain wayward phenomenological assessments and understandings of movement and of being a body, hence wayward phenomenological assessments and understandings of the aesthetic realities of dance and of dancing the dance, and more particularly the phenomenological neglect or faulty assessment and understanding of the sensory modality of kinesthesia. The writings of Merleau-Ponty and of Heidegger, and of various present-day phenomenologists such as Gallagher and Zahavi are of particular concern in this regard. Of contrasting concern are the highly informative and indeed edifying first-person experiential writings of notably famous choreographers/dancers Doris Humphrey and Merce Cunningham that highlight the centrality of kinesthesia to life as well as to dance, of notably famous theater directors Jacques Lecoq and Stanton Garner, and of music composer Roger Sessions, all three of whom write pointedly, experientially, and in thought-provoking ways of the centrality of movement to their art, in no way diminishing the uniqueness of the art of dance but both documenting and broadening the relevance of movement to aesthetic creativity.

Dance Research Journal

Aili Whalen, JD, PhD

Dance House Diary, Issue 5

Shruti Ghosh

The negotiation of significance in dance performance: aesthetic value in the context of difference’ in Farinas , R. and Van Camp, J.(eds.) The Bloomsbury Handbook of Dance and Philosophy, London and New York: Bloomsbury.

I explore how dance may be appreciated in a contemporary context in which it can no longer be assumed that performers and audience make sense of dancing with reference to a shared culture. I do not write as a philosopher, but rather from my position as a former dancer and now dance academic, to draw upon my experiences of dancing, researching and teaching dance with the aim of proposing some avenues ripe for philosophical investigation. I will start by emphasizing that dancing is a communicative phenomenon. In this context, I find the philosophy of Maurice Merleau-Ponty provides a welcome recognition of the human capacity for intersubjective, embodied experience which is of key importance to engagement with dancing as meaningful. This is not to suggest dancing can be conceived as communicative in the naïve terms that propose some sort of universal expression or movement language. Nor can the meaning of dance be directly intuited through kinesthetic empathy as proposed by early theorists of Modern dance. Rather, I consider how the significance of dance performance might be understood through a process of negotiation grounded in intercorporeal experience. Here I recognize the challenge of difference – in relation to gender, sexualities, and/or cultures and abilities - to the self-other relationships which sustain such negotiations. Finally, I situate these reflections within the broader field of philosophical aesthetics to consider the potential of such encounters to contribute to aesthetic values attributed to dance.

Dr Mark Edward

Temporality of the Dancing Body: Tears, Fears and Ageing Dears Mark Edward and Dr Helen Newall Abstract This paper examines and highlights the importance of valuing the body as it gravitates towards maturity (or ‘otherness’) refuting the myth that people do not or should not dance as they get older. It offers, as context, some of the common cultural myths of the ageing and injured dancer, and examines the career reality. It interrogates the shift from performance into dance creation of the ageing performer, and the prejudices that surround this process. Whilst ballet, as a dance form, will always remain subject to the authoritarianism of perfect technique, this paper suggests that issues in dance and the ageing body, physical scarring, psycho physical scarring and embodied knowledge are being addressed in the wider dance community, which appears at last to be moving on considerably in its appreciation of the mature mover and embodied arts practice. The paper uses as case studies, two practice-as-research projects which examined the cumulative impact of ageing values and practices as experienced across the trajectories of individual life-courses of performers, paying particular attention to dimensions of lived experience, physical and emotional pain and migrating selves. These projects also explored the subversion of notions which discriminate against the ageing dancing body, and highlighted and celebrated work which evolves with the ageing performer through somatic practice, valuing the lived process and the body as a phenomenological breathing Curriculum Vitae. The subjective nature of this paper arises out of reflexive research which is less scientific and more concerned with observations of a practice which exposes and explores, rather than sanitises, issues like emotion, pain, biography, embodiment and sensitivity. Key Words: Dance, technique, pain, injury, ageing, retirement, experience, embodiment, practice-as-research.

Una Popovic

Christina Conroy

The Bloomsbury Handbook of Dance and Philosophy

Stephen Davies

Malaika Sarco-Thomas

Asking ‘where are we now?’ this paper charts the choreographic process of four contemporary dance artists creating new work in relation to the theme of 21st Century identities. Case studies of work by UK and EU-based artists Avatâra Ayuso, Roberto Olivan, and Máté Mészáros & Nóra Horváth are examined in relation to historical influences, devising processes and directorial choices taken in an intensive rehearsal period with third year Bachelors of Dance Studies students at the University of Malta’s School of Performing Arts for an international tour in Malta and the UK. Building on sociologist Rudi Laermans’ (2015) suggestion that contemporary dance is itself a collective activity characterized by works in which artistic cooperation leads to performance product, the study asks how intensive short-term artistic projects can illustrate small but noteworthy shifts in perceptions of selfhood for performers, choreographers and audience. It investigates how choreographing can become a strategic vehicle for discovering possible actions and interactions via ‘management of possibilities’ (Foucault 2002: 341) within dancers’ identity, and as such becomes an exercise of power (Laermans 2008) to varying degrees. The study invites reflection on three key elements: first, the approaches of these early and mid-career choreographers in relation to their histories and experiences working with established European artists Shobana Jeyasingh, Anne Teresa de Keersmaker and Wim Vandekeybus. Secondly, it analyses the impact of the working process in relation to the sense of identity experienced by the dancers as performers-in-training; and a third aspect addresses audience response to the works. Studio-based observation and notation within the creation period, semi-structured interviews with choreographers and dancers, and post-performance discussions offer opportunities for data collection. In short, the paper seeks to critically illuminate what is ‘really beautiful’ about dancing for a key sample of people who continue to follow, perform and shape contemporary dance in the 21st Century.

RELATED PAPERS

Zh. Vses. Khim. o-va im D.I. Mendeleeva

Pavel Nesterenko

Studia Rossica Posnaniensia

Beata Pawletko

médecine/sciences

Edith Heard

Przegląd Uniwersytecki

Elżbieta Nowak (Stelmaszczyk)

Revista Humus

Geraldo J Ferraresi de Araujo

Statisztikai szemle: a Magyar Központi Statisztikai Hivatal folyóirata

Balázs Kotosz

HIV & AIDS Review

MATHIAS EMOKPAE

Bulletin of the American Physical Society

Erica Carlson

Japanese Psychological Research

Adrian Furnham

Journal of Cancer Therapy

Luis Gerardo Garcia-Herreros

American Journal of Medical Genetics Part C: Seminars in Medical Genetics

Faiz Raza Hassan

Alejandro Mendoza Jaramillo

Numerische Mathematik

Leszek Marcinkowski

Journal of Neuroinflammation

Leukemia Research

Yıldız Aydın

Kazuyoshi Koyama

Exercise and Quality …

Vasiliki Malliou

Dewi Baririet Baroroh

Vilius Dranseika , Tomasz Żuradzki

Medicina-lithuania

Julius Ptasekas

Diagnostic and interventional imaging

Laurent Lemaitre

The EMBO Journal

Bernard Dujon

budi widianarko

Insect Systematics & Evolution

SANDISO MNGUNI

RELATED TOPICS

•   We're Hiring!
•   Help Center
• Find new research papers in:
• Health Sciences
• Earth Sciences
• Cognitive Science
• Mathematics
• Computer Science
• Academia ©2024

Help | Advanced Search

Computer Science > Computation and Language

Title: researchagent: iterative research idea generation over scientific literature with large language models.

Abstract: Scientific Research, vital for improving human life, is hindered by its inherent complexity, slow pace, and the need for specialized experts. To enhance its productivity, we propose a ResearchAgent, a large language model-powered research idea writing agent, which automatically generates problems, methods, and experiment designs while iteratively refining them based on scientific literature. Specifically, starting with a core paper as the primary focus to generate ideas, our ResearchAgent is augmented not only with relevant publications through connecting information over an academic graph but also entities retrieved from an entity-centric knowledge store based on their underlying concepts, mined and shared across numerous papers. In addition, mirroring the human approach to iteratively improving ideas with peer discussions, we leverage multiple ReviewingAgents that provide reviews and feedback iteratively. Further, they are instantiated with human preference-aligned large language models whose criteria for evaluation are derived from actual human judgments. We experimentally validate our ResearchAgent on scientific publications across multiple disciplines, showcasing its effectiveness in generating novel, clear, and valid research ideas based on human and model-based evaluation results.

Submission history

Access paper:.

• Other Formats

References & Citations

• Google Scholar
• Semantic Scholar

BibTeX formatted citation

Bibliographic and Citation Tools

Code, data and media associated with this article, recommenders and search tools.

• Institution

arXivLabs: experimental projects with community collaborators

arXivLabs is a framework that allows collaborators to develop and share new arXiv features directly on our website.

Both individuals and organizations that work with arXivLabs have embraced and accepted our values of openness, community, excellence, and user data privacy. arXiv is committed to these values and only works with partners that adhere to them.

Have an idea for a project that will add value for arXiv's community? Learn more about arXivLabs .

• Our Program Divisions
• Our Three Academies
• Government Affairs
• Statement on Diversity and Inclusion
• Our Study Process
• Conflict of Interest Policies and Procedures
• Project Comments and Information
• Read Our Expert Reports and Published Proceedings
• Explore PNAS, the Flagship Scientific Journal of NAS
• Access Transportation Research Board Publications
• Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
• Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
• Economic Recovery
• Fellowships and Grants
• Publications by Division
• Division of Behavioral and Social Sciences and Education
• Division on Earth and Life Studies
• Division on Engineering and Physical Sciences
• Gulf Research Program
• Health and Medicine Division
• Policy and Global Affairs Division
• Transportation Research Board
• National Academy of Sciences
• National Academy of Engineering
• National Academy of Medicine
• Publications by Topic
• Agriculture
• Behavioral and Social Sciences
• Biography and Autobiography
• Biology and Life Sciences
• Computers and Information Technology
• Conflict and Security Issues
• Earth Sciences
• Energy and Energy Conservation
• Engineering and Technology
• Environment and Environmental Studies
• Food and Nutrition
• Health and Medicine
• Industry and Labor
• Math, Chemistry, and Physics
• Policy for Science and Technology
• Space and Aeronautics
• Surveys and Statistics
• Transportation and Infrastructure
• Searchable Collections
• New Releases

VIEW LARGER COVER

Advancing Clinical Research with Pregnant and Lactating Populations

Overcoming real and perceived liability risks.

Congress called on the National Academies to convene a committee to examine the real and perceived risks of liability arising from research conducted with pregnant and lactating women. The resulting report, Clinical Research with Pregnant and Lactating Populations: Overcoming Real and Perceived Liability Risks, explores and finds limited evidence of legal liability for inclusion of pregnant and lactating women in clinical research, contradicting perceptions of heightened liability. The committee also makes recommendations that could lead to a more robust evidence base about the safety and efficacy of medications for pregnant and lactating women that would facilitate more informed decision making regarding care while mitigating liability.

RESOURCES AT A GLANCE

• Policy Brief for FDA
• Policy Brief for Congress
• Policy Brief for HHS
• Policy Brief for NIH
• Infographic on Dissuasive Factors for Inclusion
• Interactive Overview

• ↓ Scroll Down for More Resources
• Health and Medicine — Women's Health
• Health and Medicine — Health Sciences
• Health and Medicine — Policy, Reviews and Evaluations

Suggested Citation

National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. 2024. Advancing Clinical Research with Pregnant and Lactating Populations: Overcoming Real and Perceived Liability Risks . Washington, DC: The National Academies Press. https://doi.org/10.17226/27595. Import this citation to: Bibtex EndNote Reference Manager

Publication Info

What is skim.

The Chapter Skim search tool presents what we've algorithmically identified as the most significant single chunk of text within every page in the chapter. You may select key terms to highlight them within pages of each chapter.

• Press Release

Overview Video

Copyright information.

The National Academies Press (NAP) has partnered with Copyright Clearance Center's Marketplace service to offer you a variety of options for reusing NAP content. Through Marketplace, you may request permission to reprint NAP content in another publication, course pack, secure website, or other media. Marketplace allows you to instantly obtain permission, pay related fees, and print a license directly from the NAP website. The complete terms and conditions of your reuse license can be found in the license agreement that will be made available to you during the online order process. To request permission through Marketplace you are required to create an account by filling out a simple online form. The following list describes license reuses offered by the NAP through Marketplace:

• Republish text, tables, figures, or images in print
• Post on a secure Intranet/Extranet website
• Use in a PowerPoint Presentation
• Distribute via CD-ROM

Click here to obtain permission for the above reuses. If you have questions or comments concerning the Marketplace service, please contact:

Marketplace Support International +1.978.646.2600 US Toll Free +1.855.239.3415 E-mail: [email protected] marketplace.copyright.com

To request permission to distribute a PDF, please contact our Customer Service Department at [email protected] .

What is a prepublication?

An uncorrected copy, or prepublication, is an uncorrected proof of the book. We publish prepublications to facilitate timely access to the committee's findings.

What happens when I pre-order?

The final version of this book has not been published yet. You can pre-order a copy of the book and we will send it to you when it becomes available. We will not charge you for the book until it ships. Pricing for a pre-ordered book is estimated and subject to change. All backorders will be released at the final established price. As a courtesy, if the price increases by more than $3.00 we will notify you. If the price decreases, we will simply charge the lower price. Applicable discounts will be extended.

Downloading and Using eBooks from NAP

What is an ebook.

An ebook is one of two file formats that are intended to be used with e-reader devices and apps such as Amazon Kindle or Apple iBooks.

Why is an eBook better than a PDF?

A PDF is a digital representation of the print book, so while it can be loaded into most e-reader programs, it doesn't allow for resizable text or advanced, interactive functionality. The eBook is optimized for e-reader devices and apps, which means that it offers a much better digital reading experience than a PDF, including resizable text and interactive features (when available).

Where do I get eBook files?

eBook files are now available for a large number of reports on the NAP.edu website. If an eBook is available, you'll see the option to purchase it on the book page.

View more FAQ's about Ebooks

Types of Publications

Consensus Study Report: Consensus Study Reports published by the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine document the evidence-based consensus on the study’s statement of task by an authoring committee of experts. Reports typically include findings, conclusions, and recommendations based on information gathered by the committee and the committee’s deliberations. Each report has been subjected to a rigorous and independent peer-review process and it represents the position of the National Academies on the statement of task.

AI Index Report

Welcome to the seventh edition of the AI Index report. The 2024 Index is our most comprehensive to date and arrives at an important moment when AI’s influence on society has never been more pronounced. This year, we have broadened our scope to more extensively cover essential trends such as technical advancements in AI, public perceptions of the technology, and the geopolitical dynamics surrounding its development. Featuring more original data than ever before, this edition introduces new estimates on AI training costs, detailed analyses of the responsible AI landscape, and an entirely new chapter dedicated to AI’s impact on science and medicine.

Read the 2024 AI Index Report

The AI Index report tracks, collates, distills, and visualizes data related to artificial intelligence (AI). Our mission is to provide unbiased, rigorously vetted, broadly sourced data in order for policymakers, researchers, executives, journalists, and the general public to develop a more thorough and nuanced understanding of the complex field of AI.

The AI Index is recognized globally as one of the most credible and authoritative sources for data and insights on artificial intelligence. Previous editions have been cited in major newspapers, including the The New York Times, Bloomberg, and The Guardian, have amassed hundreds of academic citations, and been referenced by high-level policymakers in the United States, the United Kingdom, and the European Union, among other places. This year’s edition surpasses all previous ones in size, scale, and scope, reflecting the growing significance that AI is coming to hold in all of our lives.

Steering Committee Co-Directors

Ray Perrault

Steering committee members.

Erik Brynjolfsson

John Etchemendy

Katrina Ligett

Terah Lyons

James Manyika

Juan Carlos Niebles

Vanessa Parli

Yoav Shoham

Russell Wald

Staff members.

Loredana Fattorini

Nestor Maslej

Letter from the co-directors.

A decade ago, the best AI systems in the world were unable to classify objects in images at a human level. AI struggled with language comprehension and could not solve math problems. Today, AI systems routinely exceed human performance on standard benchmarks.

Progress accelerated in 2023. New state-of-the-art systems like GPT-4, Gemini, and Claude 3 are impressively multimodal: They can generate fluent text in dozens of languages, process audio, and even explain memes. As AI has improved, it has increasingly forced its way into our lives. Companies are racing to build AI-based products, and AI is increasingly being used by the general public. But current AI technology still has significant problems. It cannot reliably deal with facts, perform complex reasoning, or explain its conclusions.

AI faces two interrelated futures. First, technology continues to improve and is increasingly used, having major consequences for productivity and employment. It can be put to both good and bad uses. In the second future, the adoption of AI is constrained by the limitations of the technology. Regardless of which future unfolds, governments are increasingly concerned. They are stepping in to encourage the upside, such as funding university R&D and incentivizing private investment. Governments are also aiming to manage the potential downsides, such as impacts on employment, privacy concerns, misinformation, and intellectual property rights.

As AI rapidly evolves, the AI Index aims to help the AI community, policymakers, business leaders, journalists, and the general public navigate this complex landscape. It provides ongoing, objective snapshots tracking several key areas: technical progress in AI capabilities, the community and investments driving AI development and deployment, public opinion on current and potential future impacts, and policy measures taken to stimulate AI innovation while managing its risks and challenges. By comprehensively monitoring the AI ecosystem, the Index serves as an important resource for understanding this transformative technological force.

On the technical front, this year’s AI Index reports that the number of new large language models released worldwide in 2023 doubled over the previous year. Two-thirds were open-source, but the highest-performing models came from industry players with closed systems. Gemini Ultra became the first LLM to reach human-level performance on the Massive Multitask Language Understanding (MMLU) benchmark; performance on the benchmark has improved by 15 percentage points since last year. Additionally, GPT-4 achieved an impressive 0.97 mean win rate score on the comprehensive Holistic Evaluation of Language Models (HELM) benchmark, which includes MMLU among other evaluations.

Although global private investment in AI decreased for the second consecutive year, investment in generative AI skyrocketed. More Fortune 500 earnings calls mentioned AI than ever before, and new studies show that AI tangibly boosts worker productivity. On the policymaking front, global mentions of AI in legislative proceedings have never been higher. U.S. regulators passed more AI-related regulations in 2023 than ever before. Still, many expressed concerns about AI’s ability to generate deepfakes and impact elections. The public became more aware of AI, and studies suggest that they responded with nervousness.

Ray Perrault Co-director, AI Index

Our Supporting Partners

Analytics & Research Partners

Stay up to date on the AI Index by subscribing to the  Stanford HAI newsletter.